I am probably being horribly stereotypical but is it too much for me to hope that Sin is a lover of the ladies?

Precisely. Hark! A Vagrant is the best

Good call, he did seem more like Island!Oliver in that fight than The Arrow Oliver.

Australians ARE crazy like that.

Since Spartacus I pretty much want Manu Bennett in all the things

He just wants his friend back!

Maybe Slade doesn't want Oliver dead, maybe he just wants to give him membership in the fetching-eyepatch club.

His arms were probably just tired from all the salmon laddering

I agree with your confusion.

John and Jedekiah are the most interesting characters on this show, so I very much appreciated the emphasis on their characters in this episode. They actually have an interesting backstory. It was great to get some shading on Jedekiah's character and learn that he really does care about John. (Though didn't he try to…

Ealy was also on another show that was also about slashbaity cop partners without ever intending following through, Common Law. They sent the bickering partners to marriage counseling!

They should just cast everyone from Spartacus in this at this point.

Yes. Some guys are dreamy and some guys are hot.

How did Katrina go from being a plain dressed Quaker girl to someone who goes to balls, wears gowns, and has a rich fop arranged marriage?

I like your explanation.

I wonder why he was replaced. So he could do Pacific Rim?

That would be pretty much any fanfiction.

I totally thought it was Rob Lowe as St Elmo's Fire Rob Lowe.

Kurt said he was going to show Blaine over Skype.

I admittedly don't know from personal experience, but shouldn't Kurt's tongue piercing be further back for maximum effect?