I wrote something similar below; glad to see someone agrees with me!

After last week's "C" debacle and this "A-" review, all I can say is that Emily Guendelsberger and I have very different senses of humor—and very different opinions about what makes a good "Sunny" episode. To me, "seeing the main characters out of the context of the Gang," as she nicely puts it, is not a cause for…

After last week's "C" debacle and this "A-" review, all I can say is that Emily Guendelsberger and I have very different senses of humor—and very different opinions about what makes a good "Sunny" episode. To me, "seeing the main characters out of the context of the Gang," as she nicely puts it, is not a cause for…

I've liked this season a lot so far, but this episode was a stinker. TERRIBLE WRITING THROUGHOUT. Except for the last scene, this episode bored me. Hard to get through, actually. And all the other episodes this season have been so good! 

I've liked this season a lot so far, but this episode was a stinker. TERRIBLE WRITING THROUGHOUT. Except for the last scene, this episode bored me. Hard to get through, actually. And all the other episodes this season have been so good! 

Yeah, and therefore C means one of the very worst episodes they've ever
made—which this episode certainly was not. There have been episodes
where I hardly even cracked a smile (I recall "Dennis Gets Divorced" being particularly bad). No one is saying it should be an A necessarily, just that it's not a C. Personally I…

Yeah, and therefore C means one of the very worst episodes they've ever
made—which this episode certainly was not. There have been episodes
where I hardly even cracked a smile (I recall "Dennis Gets Divorced" being particularly bad). No one is saying it should be an A necessarily, just that it's not a C. Personally I…

Missed the mark just means I don't agree with the low grade. How many C episodes has Sunny ever got? I scrolled back through the reviews from previous season and I don't see any (just a few C+s). So by your grading logic this is the worst episode they've ever done? Because you thought the plot was too predictable and…

Missed the mark just means I don't agree with the low grade. How many C episodes has Sunny ever got? I scrolled back through the reviews from previous season and I don't see any (just a few C+s). So by your grading logic this is the worst episode they've ever done? Because you thought the plot was too predictable and…

Ass, meet hole.

Ass, meet hole.

"When I started watching the show a few seasons in … "

"When I started watching the show a few seasons in … "

More specific about what was funny about the episode? Charlie barking at the guy walking down the street, Dee almost puking right before the credits, Charlie going nuts on that cheese plate, Dee's pit stains, Dennis's incredulity in the car as he watched the date, Dennis's tennis technique, Dennis popping his shirt…

More specific about what was funny about the episode? Charlie barking at the guy walking down the street, Dee almost puking right before the credits, Charlie going nuts on that cheese plate, Dee's pit stains, Dennis's incredulity in the car as he watched the date, Dennis's tennis technique, Dennis popping his shirt…

Horrible grade.

Horrible grade.

Does an episode being funny count towards its grade, because I laughed my ass off at this one. Once again, the A.V. Club seems to have managed to assign some Johnny-come-lately reviewer who doesn't really know what she's talking about. This year's Emily is better than last year's Emily so far (it would almost be…

Does an episode being funny count towards its grade, because I laughed my ass off at this one. Once again, the A.V. Club seems to have managed to assign some Johnny-come-lately reviewer who doesn't really know what she's talking about. This year's Emily is better than last year's Emily so far (it would almost be…

Great episode. Everyone involved is beasting it this year.