Josh… if you even read these comments. I say this with love: I need to check your bad opinion on this "veteran with traumatic brain injury, plot." Ok, I get it. Quinn was the missing piece of the spy game. Season 4, "18 hrs in Islamabad" he was everything we want out of a Bourne-Bondish layered character. Frankly,…

Cole and Alison.

that's what I mean!

I'll go back and watch. My take stays the same. None of the out of prison scenes are actually Gunther. It is in Noah's head.

helen saw him where?

He wasn't in the basement. He didn't hit him w/ car. Figment of Noah's mind. Is he real? Sure. Maybe he is a guard, I don't rem him in another POV, but to me the stalking Figment of Noah's mind.

the son dying and aftermath is so wrenching to me. Cole/Allison I love.

it is. finale is in paris.

he clearly exists but is not doing these things

He's not having a flashback. It's in his head. He doesn't exist.

Yeah. Plus it's 3 seasons of watching the same guy deteriorate. Repetitive. As you say, hitting a soap-y level of merry go round.

DW was super good, but that scene, was like selfish.com to me. He wanted to go to college. He let his mom kill herself, and helped her. He's vile.

circle. drain.

Isn't that Hitchcock direction a good sign? Can Noah find a rear window?

Best episode in certain recent memory, and will go off as one of my top picks. It's intense. Josh sells the layered do-good provider; husband; father figure — while allowing us to see what is underneath. He's just a guy who lost his kid and wife. The only thing he's ever really wanted and loved. And seeing this…

i don't get some of the critism in this review. I think the point of Carrie's would-be assination of Haqqani, is that it was character development. She was willing to die herself — she saved Quinn from basic suicide, offering herself. I say bravo. This is a woman who started out almost drowning her kid- to now be…