Then you compare it to Valve’s response to fans recreating Half-Life from scratch, the Black Mesa project. Not only valve allowed them to continue the recreation, they also allowed them to sell BM on the very platform they own: Steam (probably sharing revenue, but still).

According to some apologists here, Valve would…

But then we have Valve’s example... not only they let a group of random people remake Half-Life 1, their own worthy IP without even C&Ding them (like one could expect Nintendo to do), but Valve also let them distribute and even later SELL it on their own plataform, Steam, in the form of a standalone game (“Black…