True, there is also an issue of pride though.  If he has been off on his own living off small stick-ups and being run out of every town he’s gone to, would he really want to tell Sadie, who is now a one woman wrecking machine, that he couldn’t take care of himself and his family the way he always had in the past? …

I would guess 18 hours was about how long it took if you just played the main story, but I don’t know because I didn’t play the first one. I would guess that halfway through chapter 4 is MAYBE halfway through the game. Maybe. The first two chapters were pretty short and they get more in depth as you go. Chapter 5 is…

Yes it does.  You also get jumped a lot more at night, but it’s easier to find camps to loot too.  Just watch out when you are crossing bridges, bastards like to hide behind bridges and try to rob you.  

The story line is kind of a ride.  There are times you don’t really care about your actions because of your own, or the group’s needs, then you later reflect on those moments, and in the end, the way you go out is the way you lived.

I see, now that you mention it I did catch that comment. John has told people a couple other things too, that he just fell on hard times, and he mentions that he was robbed at one point as well. I just took it as John making something up on the spot so he doesn’t have to tell what he really did with the money. I’m…

Ok, that makes sense. Is that mentioned somewhere? The only story I really caught at the beginning of the epilogue was John’s wife telling him she is tired of having to move every couple weeks because John does something in the town. I just assumed they had lost the money somehow or had it stolen from them, but wasn’t…

My brother and I both played through it so I got to see parts of his bad guy story, but I finished the game with full morality.  I don’t think it changes the game in a huge way, but when you are reflecting on your life and the people in it, the cut scenes and dialogue are different.  The ending to chapter 6 is pretty…

I think you should have your valuables in your satchel by now, if not it will be soon. I’m just a little passed getting the loan.  I’m guessing you probably get satchel stuff back when you get all your custom guns back.  That is when I noticed I had mine back anyway.

I liked Arthur much better than John too, but starting the game over is a commitment.

I’m with you in that I’m kind of sad that I’m John now. I almost wish I would have slowed down, or just not played the last mission yet. The way the story of Arthur Morgan unwinds is pretty personal to the way you behave as him. And in the end, you are either dead in the mud, or looking into the sunset with dignity,…

The way the cut scenes and dialogue change depending on morality is really cool. If you are a bad guy, people talk about how you are bad, and have gotten what you deserved, and if you are good, people talk about all the great things you did for others. I can’t imagine how much time they spent recording just the…

Have you completed the whole story yet?  Getting through the whole story in 50 hours would be pretty tough, even if all you were doing was the main story line.

In my experience, there was nothing overly frustrating in Red Dead 2 in story missions.  The story was actually pretty easy to get through, it just takes time.  When they made this game, I don’t think they really focused on making it difficult so much as they focused on making sure the story was entertaining the…

True, but Red Dead 2 is like 50 hour if you burn through it as fast as you can.  The game takes a long time to complete.  If only 10% of people went through a game that was 18 hours long if you power through, how many will finish a game that is 50 hours if you power through?  

What I have found to be even more amazing is the way the story, cut scenes, and dialogue change depending on the morality of you behavior. The only reason I know this my brother played through it as well and we had some pretty different cut scenes and dialogue, especially toward the end.

No to the money, you get the valuables that were in the satchel, but not tonics, health cures, food, or the money. You do get all your weapons back, and I’m pretty sure you have all the outfits you bought during the main story unlocked. Basically, you should spend any cash Arthur has left in chapter 6 and keep any…

Anybody run across a little shack with a skeleton on the front porch that looks like it is maybe a gypsy woman?  The shack is pretty colorful on the outside, and there really isn’t anything around.  I found it once and there was a skeleton dressed in what looked like gypsy clothing and I found a “woman’s fertility…

They would sign him, but as soon as the Bills released him both the Browns organization, and John Gruden simultaneously called “dibs”, so they will now face off in rock-paper-scissors, best of three of course, to see who gets him.  The craziest part is, they wouldn’t have to give anything up to sign him, but they…

That’s what I thought too.  how can you not see passed the visor when it is down?  Do you drive with your face against your windshield or some shit Drew?

The Lions do have one very big thing going for them.  They aren’t the Browns.