The finale wasn't quite as well thought-out as it could've been, but I think the reason for the show's failure in the ratings lies overall in the trope known as Unpleasable Fanbase.

What, no mention of the Family Feud sketch with the Electric Mayhem? That was the best part. "Um, I try not to eat ice cream, because I think it's mean that they keep cows in a freezer." "Cows are lab experiments by the government. That's why there were no cows before 1972. I challenge you to find me a cow born before…