Indeed someone has. Just Google "Empty Cup Awards", and read: http://www.slate.com/blogs/…

Reality is not kind to the state of New Jersey.

I think she meant it was a last minute decision for Chuck to do that, not for her to write it. She said it wasn't Chuck's plan from the beginning to 'seduce' Hannah, but he just thought he felt a connection once they were in the bedroom.

I think you're confusing 'fans' with 'students'.

That's exactly why it was such a bad idea to write that scene into the episode, because you can point to it and completely invalidate every argument that came before.