Fercita: I was responding to your line "False, it has always stated what she thought of comics."

That scene came to my mind, too. It's a good example of what we're talking about because it probably upsets D&D purists…but in the end, how cool is it that D&D even features in, let alone dominates, the Christmas episode of one of the most popular shows on television? Topical references are a no-no in a lot of art…

I agree. It's easy to trace continuity issues in any sitcom, but Sheldon is a tricky character because he has so many "rules" and, once we're familiar with them, we want to hold him accountable.

I'm not saying that this was the first episode that her aversion became clear; you're right that we've known that for a while. But her introduction in the 3rd season finale sort of implied that she was the female equivalent of Sheldon, and it wasn't until the 4th season premiered (and progressed) that we learned how…

I think I acknowledged that point, though without the distinction between nerds and geeks (I wasn't aware there was one).

I don't understand why people who claim to have no interest in this show are reading an article about it and commenting to said article.