The Oberon parallels are there but most of the plot for that story was ripped right out of 1959's Imitation of Life, about a black maid whose daughter grows up in a white world and passes for white.

I agree, sort of. I thought that Claire's reaction needed to be more shock and horror at Geillis' murder of a seemingly innocent person. That moment of realizing what Geillis had done was kind of brushed over in the show. I think in the book Mr. Gillian Edgars was painted as a drunk and wife beater so you were made to…

Can't believe no one brought up the ridiculous Dexter-style opening. Why anyone would want to make a nod to that show, after it it went down in flames, is beyond me. I had heard that the serial killer story was going to be lame, but I had hope that it was going to turn out to be one of the characters we already knew…

Yes!! This annoyed me so much! And I disagree with the reviewer that it was plausible that the gang would finally find Job now that Fat Au was helping. Why wouldn't they get his help earlier? Carrie tried everything to find Job? No she didn't. She waited two years to call her friend, and Job's, who specializes in…

Sorry, I'm not really enjoying which is linked to why I'm asking. ;)

Hmm. Why the slow aging? That seems like a weird fix just so they could put Noble in the role. Sorry, I know you didn't write it, but was that explained?

I was afraid that was the reason. Doesn't work for me, and I'm losing patience with certain elements of this show.

Can someone explain to me why Ichabod's son is evil and why in the hell is he old. I know I was really confused about this last season but thought it would be explained this season.

Ugh! Yes! Either Janette has some sort of memory or hearing problem or that was just really bad writing. They made it a point to have a scene where Feeney gets up in her face and says 'You can't use your name. I own it.' Next thing she's painting a sign with her name on it. WTF?

While I'm enjoying the show, more than I expected, I find everything to do with Carrie's crush on Sebastian to be an utter bore. I get that he's the (way too cliched) sexy, new boy in school with the rogueish smirk, but why are we supposed to care about this character? Did I miss the part where he did or said anything…