See? He also had a role in a certain apocalyptic movie, but I won't discuss it here because it would be hella spoiler-y.

B&B's in other countries don't count. The people there are clearly not as uptight as the weird New England septuagenarians whose antique cupboards are covered with tchotchkes that make Precious Moments figurines look like The Thinker. I think you just relayed that anecdote to tell everyone: a) You've been to San…

Wait — Guy Pearce is the one who needs a bigger career. L.A. Confidential, Memento, then.... what? The shriveled guy in Prometheus? What happened to him?

I'll be there in my Dodge Dart.

I'm actually a little older, but yeah, those were indeed the days. But wait — aren't we supposed to be arguing or calling each other douches or driving 35 minutes to fight or something?

Ok, fair enough. Nicely researched. However, there's no getting around the fact that Wilkins went super-human in this game and it still wasn't enough to get him past Bird.

Wilkins gets a bad rap — he just couldn't get his team past Bird's Celtics, one of the all-time great squads.

Ok, I'm kind of done trying to explain why Jay had a valid motive, that he's shown he's unhinged, and that he had a greater opportunity to kill Hae than Adnan did. You can continue clinging to the belief that he's just kind of a weird low-level drug dealer who tried to stab a friend, but definitely NOT a murderer…

Did he really laugh it off? Kind of, but how much do you really laugh it off when someone tries to fucking stab you? And what has Adnan done that was weird and sketchy like that? Nothing.

I can't see that at all. Jay is a bullshitter to the point of being a sociopath, and he tried to stab a friend. With a knife. Adnan never showed anything like that, and no one thought he was that upset about the breakup.

Does it make more sense that Adnan would go from golden boy to murderer? (Remember: Jay tried to stab a friend.)

Jay had Adnan's cellphone.

He wrote that, yes, but pretty much everyone said he had moved on. So you're weighing that more than the people who said he was fine after their breakup, than the fact that he supposedly killed her, hustled back to track, and practiced without acting weird enough to arouse any suspicion? You're cherry-picking…

Writing about killing Hae once at the top of a journal is a pretty far cry from actually doing it. I don't know about asking Hae for a ride that day, but everyone has pretty much exploded the possibility that he could have done it within that afternoon timeframe. Lastly, Don didn't try to contact her, either. Very…

Who knows? There was a lot we don't know. Just because we don't know Jay's motive doesn't mean jack to me. The guy was seriously bad news. Maybe he did it simply for kicks, to see if he could get away with it.

My trouble is, I feel like Adnan wasn't involved, but it seems he may have been a little. But how is one "a little" involved in a murder? If he was involved at all, what was his role? I can't square it.

That's pretty circumstantial.

Where is the evidence linking Adnan to any of this? "Bad luck"? Cell-tower pings that don't quite sync up? Those wouldn't hold up in any court not prejudiced by overzealous racist prosecutors and a messed-up, dying, likely drug-addicted defense attorney with a voice as soothing as nails on a chalkboard.

Disagree. Jay is a complete and total bullshitter ("The West Side hitman? Please) and was likely involved. He tossed his clothes and a shovel, for fuck's sake. I'm not sure of Adnan's role, but there's pretty much nothing except the flimsiest of connections tying him to Hae's murder. Plus, Adnan never showed any…

Yeah, communist! Go back to commie-land and keep on being a commie!