You're clearly very irrational and butthurt about something; the guy didn't say anything remotely like that.

It has an average professional critic score on metacritic; audience reviews are very good and generally confused by the lukewarm reception of the critics. The idea that all, or even a large minority, of the reviews have been 'terrible', is just plain nonsense.

"So far, critical responses to The Hobbit have been terrible".

One of Valve's voice actors (John Lowrie) has just said that he hasn't recorded anything for HL3, and that he "had a conversation with a Valve employee recently about some of the challenges involved in making an HL3".

...how does one 'solve a theorem'?