I’ve never fully understood this argument.

That’s a convincing argument. I concede. I mean if some random dude says they’re garbage, that must make it true!

Your lack of understanding analogies is further proof that thinking is hard for you.

I know NOTHING about any of this, but these arguments seem to contradict each other.

“Hey guys, we just won the Super Bowl with Trent Dilfer at QB. No need to change!”

Fuck Jeter’s Gold Gloves.

By EVERY measurement Arod was a better fielder.

Arod’s 2003 wRC+ = 151
Giles’s 2003 wRC+ = 146

They created basically the same pure offensive value.
And this wasn’t a fluke cherry-picked by Marchman.