Carl got the hat and gun combo back. I'm content now.

I thought this was a pretty good episode, but i disagree on Diaz. Huck and Diaz's acting is one of the shows very strong highlights for me, especially this season. Him questioning Quinn and her motivations was very good, and his care for her in a way that he doesn't want her trying to go down the path he has gone is…

I do find it hilariously amusing now that Caroline and Stefan are getting even closer and presumably going to be in a lot more scenes together, TYLER decides to pop back up. Writers nowadays really do love the love triangle, don't they?

With a show with so many episodes, of course some dip lower than the usual one, and Elementary definitely has the tiny bits of episodes that aren't the greatest, but this one I felt wasn't one of them and me personally, I certainly would have given it at least a B.

Sin is Canary's adopted daughter.

A couple more things I'll like to add:
Sin was great, just because of the comics reference of the character and being tied up with Black Canary.
Slade! Poor, poor Slade Wilson. At least now we know what happens to have caused such a rift between them (presumably), which should lead to Slade coming to the present day…

I definitely thoroughly enjoyed this episode. From all the easter eggs that they kept dishing out to Canary and the creative way they brought in the Canary Cry (at least until they bring in superpowers with Flash of course) was great. I could have dealt without like the 3 "52" references they had, I thought that was…

I loved this episode. SHAW!

Oh no, I meant it as a positive thing. I was referring to other shows.

I thoroughly enjoyed the episode. Of course I love fire people so that perhaps helped. Chloe Bennet is very, very good to look at, and they could have all the extended dialogue they want with her in her bra and panties.

I do love me some Halloween episodes… when it's actually Halloween time!

Ashley Benson and her boobs. Yes.

Yes, yes, yes! I'm so damn happy about this.

I'm excited for this only because Pacific Rim's Travis Beacham is involved.

I would probably give this episode a B+, but a B is still a very solid grade. Benanti did a splendid job, which I didn't quite realize until I was watching the actual episode that she was from Go On but there she was.

Reading this review, I just realized I didn't get my RIPPAAAAAAAAAAH tonight. EH?!

- To start, Emily Bett Rickards in that dress looked absolutely mind blowing. Every time she turned, that ass was right there. Like really, right there.

Sigh. This seems to be going in the route of "I'll read the reviews but stay far, far, far away from the comments where people who call it the worst show ever still come back weekly to complain like ignorant, foolish children and they apparently literally have children writing in the comments."

Best episode of the show, definitely. I truly think it's going to stick around for at least another year.

I enjoyed this episode. Not as much as previous ones unfortunately, and I called Carter's partner was tied up with NEFARIOUS acts from the get-go, but it was still fun.