wrongsirwrong--disqus
Magic Xylophone
wrongsirwrong--disqus

I know this is a week late, but I had to respond. I read that script too, and felt exactly the opposite. While Spaihts' draft has some flaws, and isn't the backstory for the Alienverse that I'd want, it's better than what I saw in theaters in almost every way:
An archaeologist believing aliens created humanity because

I know this is a week late, but I had to respond. I read that script too, and felt exactly the opposite. While Spaihts' draft has some flaws, and isn't the backstory for the Alienverse that I'd want, it's better than what I saw in theaters in almost every way:
An archaeologist believing aliens created humanity because

Here's a simple test: does Avatar take the most mysterious, most otherworldly, most oft-speculated-on element of a classic scifi film and reveal that it is LITERALLY a guy in a suit, and also God? No? Then it cannot be as bad as Prometheus.

Here's a simple test: does Avatar take the most mysterious, most otherworldly, most oft-speculated-on element of a classic scifi film and reveal that it is LITERALLY a guy in a suit, and also God? No? Then it cannot be as bad as Prometheus.

I love the boring parts! Zooming in on that photo, I was like "Holy shit!" when he managed to discover those synthetic snake scales. 

I love the boring parts! Zooming in on that photo, I was like "Holy shit!" when he managed to discover those synthetic snake scales. 

A cliffhanger is different from ill-defined character motivations and an opaque mythos. Also, having a sequel end that way is different from having a prequel/reboot/spinoff end that way.

A cliffhanger is different from ill-defined character motivations and an opaque mythos. Also, having a sequel end that way is different from having a prequel/reboot/spinoff end that way.

Me too. In fact, I probably would have liked it a lot more if I hadn't watched Alien right before it.

Me too. In fact, I probably would have liked it a lot more if I hadn't watched Alien right before it.

Those T-shirts weren't ironic.

Those T-shirts weren't ironic.

The Magical Mr. Mephistopheles?

The Magical Mr. Mephistopheles?

I like "___ Harder"

I like "___ Harder"

Seems like they'd be more to blame for knife crimes.

Seems like they'd be more to blame for knife crimes.

Your adherence to the Old Ways is admirable. Never change.

Your adherence to the Old Ways is admirable. Never change.