I think you should remove race/gender/whatever from the equation if it doesn't directly affect a person's actions and judge the character as well-developed or not. Then add the race/gender/whatever back in and judge it on that.

True.

Redwall is good, but it always has greatness just within reach but (apart from Martin the Warrior and The Pearls of Lutra) never really bothers to go out and be the best thing ever.

True; it had its moments though I never felt the super-consistency in the scenes that Avatar or Korra had. When it was on the ball though, it really was something though.

It's because CGI is so obviously fake in almost everything while animation is able to fluidly join the real and the fantasy.

I think it goes for action a bit as well. I love Arrow, but no action scene in it (barring his confrontations with the Dark Archer and Deathstroke) comes close to the Legend of Korra fight scene standard for example.

"I am the Inquisitor! I am the rebel-slayer! I will capture the Jedi!"

I never saw Zoe as more competent than Mal. He always seemed better at keeping his diverse crew in line most of the time.

Never even watched the show but looked up the Kanan vs Inquisitor fight up on youtube and I was impressed to say the least. I will have to keep and eye on this.

I used to like his reviews but they got so bad it's actually funny.

I think the true manly ideal is the balance of strength and resources - having power but refusing to use it unnecessarily. Therefore, I'm going to go with Vash the Stampede from Trigun.

He did risk his life to save another man he was brought up to hate. As fictional characters go, he's pretty decent in my book. Plus, sometimes its hard to separate classism and just being a plain classy individual.

Vimes is like the ultimate cop. I definitely think he's the best part of any book that focuses on him.

There are four types of comments on AT reviews:

This is going to be my last post on the topic since I have other stuff to do so

Then why are you rising to the bait? Especially when his point this time is pretty much valid.

To be fair, Sava does seem to analyse the gender politics in episodes where it isn't really a focus or even barely related. See the LoK finale, for example. And lots of other people are saying that they thought this grade was really unfair.

Underanalysis is rarely the problem with his reviews. I think he just mistook the episode as one with no depth and so did not try to analyse it.

The episodes that focus on Superboy are his best (like the one where he and Megan are sent to prison) since he's forced to be smart. So I agree that in any mass fight scene he usually ends up on the receiving end of punishment.

I really hope they make a sequel. I would definitely buy it.