LOL I know, I just replied to my thread about it.

I think so too. Probably raised as a boy. The "sister" thing is the ultimate red herring.

If Pete is the killer, then the ones who live on are probably Grace, Chanel, No. 3, Zayday, and Hester or Chad Denise. Ryan changes his mind allllll the time though, so who knows. He once famously said none of the AHS universes are connected, then BOOM season 4 changes his mind and now All are connected??? So who…

She seemed legit scared though at the sight of the RD in the maze though. She definitely has a motive but I feel like she will actually be one of the next victims.

Just rewatched Episode 1, I thought Melanie had died, nope. Dean Munsch said "assault", so it could be Melanie. So maybe it was her brother Boone who looked at her in that last second when she was on the floor?

It seems at this point it's either Hester or Pete in some kind of Sleepaway Camp-homage to transgender killer scenario. All the other characters have alibis….. It's a stretch for me but once again, they keep looping back to Melanie Dorkus' death AND the penultimate episode title IS Dorkus, so maybe one of the Chanels…

Small detail but it's Chanel No. 3, not 5, who refers to KKT as "home" when barging out of her parents' house.

LOL

Whitney ALMOST gives Dana from Homeland a run for her money. Showtime does not take too kindly to self-important first born females.

I like that theory. Maybe Pete is like the killer in Sorority Row (2009), the killer who cares lol. Or he just had a last minute change of heart. After all, Gigi did raise whoever Red Devil 2 is.

Agreed. With 3 episodes left what could possibly be left for him to do?

In the same thread I've changed my mind but now I'm convinced it's Pete, who's been absent from way too many episodes lately…..or a slight chance of Hester not being really dead and it's her. But she also seems like the ultimate red herring

For narrative purposes, because Gaga tells the model early on "You…. Remind me of someone." So she means Valentino. For Ryan Murphy purposes, because Finn Wittrock is a fan fave of AHS so he's just giving him more scenery to chew on.

That was planned. Gaga said early on to Finn "you….. Remind me of someone"

Gaga's shriek at the end was the best acting she's done all season. "That's… What was BAAACKK THERE?!?!?" Had to rewatched a couple times. She brought the terror.

Maybe Hester isn't you younger. Maybe she waited 2 years to enroll to coincide with rushing Kappa at the time a neck brace like her could, when Gigi could sneak in a plea to open rush to all girls.

Just rewatched Episode 1, it was Gigi's suggestion to open rush to "all girls". Now I'm more convinced it's Hester. Gigi waited till Hester was old enough to enroll and came in the year she was ready to embark on her revenge plan to ensure Hester would become a pledge of the house. Gotta be Hester and Boone as the…

LOL literally posted a similar sentiment 3 seconds before you did. YES. EXACTLY. what was the point of him being gay? It's like they had to connect the dots with why Zayday was kidnapped. I almost feel like they had 5 different scripts and we're not sure how to piece it together.

If Boone was just pretending to be gay, how come he got a boner from sleeping with Chad that night that Chanel stormed in?? Maybe they missed that small detail. I'm doubting the existence of Script Supervisors on Ryan shows.

How can it be? She was shocked to see Boone alive and blew his cover to the other Chanels. Makes no sense