This episode just reaffirmed my belief that Katrina is actually evil.

I would LOVE it if Katrina turned out to be the Ultimate Big Bad. It's almost as if the writers are writing her to be, but don't realize it.

SERIOUSLY! That was the thing that made her story scream out, "I am lying about this whole thing!" It just doesn't make sense the La Llorana knockoff was drowning people unless she herself drowned.

Katrina is such an unreliable narrator, but the show doesn't seem to realize that. I still side-eye her and distrust everything she said after that story about how Ichabod's first fiancee died. Seriously, how can you trust the judgement or the word of someone who lied about someone DYING and secretly buried the corpse?

A witch and a midwife actually makes sense, but yeah, it's starting to get a bit ridiculous with both of them doing everything and being totes besties with all the big names.

Caroline and Ichabod had so much more chemistry in a few minutes than Ichabod and Katrina have had in every single scene they've been in. Nothing about them screams "happily married couple deeply in love." No matter how much the show insists they are, it just doesn't come across. You're exactly right, that it's all…

It's pretty clear their dislike of Abbie's character is not due to the writing, shall we say.

You seem like a pleasant person. :/

You know there was more than just "Jim Crow segregation," right? Look up "sundown towns." Guess what, those were all over the country.

And there was a line where a solider dude said they'd searched the city and found no one (which is when they were ordered to the train station), which made it pretty clear the city had been evacuated. They did great set-up for it.

You really want validation, huh.

It wouldn't be so bad if they took the time to develop the romance bits, but they're just plopping it in out of no where. Like, with Hawley and his thing for Abbie - where did that even come from? There's been little to no indication up until this episode that he had any interest in her. So wtf. It's like the writers…

I'm convinced they hired her just because she looks like a very young Michelle Pfeiffer.

He's an unlockable character in Hatoful Boyfriend.

The most interesting thing they did with her, with the La Llorona story, they seem to have completely forgotten about, which is how suddenly not so trustworthy, and therefore actually kind of complex, that made her. For a moment, it was, "ooh, is she not all that she seems?" and now pbbbth, she's back to being the…

There had better be gifs and such with "I must Internet! Immediately!" on it, or else tumblr will have let me down horribly.

The farm bits would have made a great two-parter, maybe even three eps. A whole season was just painful.

Yeah. When it looked like he was joining the team, I gave a cheer, then he squashed my dreams with him asking for a recommendation letter for Quantico, and…no, no, keep him and ditch the blond dweeb!

Personally, if I woke up and saw the entire city had turned into a big ol' forest, I would say, "Yeah, this is a back to bed day" and assume work was cancelled due to giant honking forest and would stay inside in my PJs.

Yeah, I saw that bit, and rolled my eyes accordingly.