Hey, I'm not 100% sold on there even being different timelines, so I may be entirely off-base. However, I am reluctantly seeing that the multiple timelines almost certainly has to be the case, but I think I'll have to rewatch the entire season to untangle what happened when and how it makes sense. If they pull that…

Everyone who argues against my theory is essentially saying "William becoming MIB is more surprising" which actually negates any surprise because you all already think that is going to happen. How is that surprising??

This episode made clear that while MIB has been coming to the park for 30 years, he hasn't been CONTINUOUSLY visiting the park during that entire time as we were led to assume. According to MIB's own story, he came to the park again AFTER 30 years, motivated by his wife's suicide, so there was a VERY significant gap…

It makes much more sense that MIB is Logan, not William. William would have to change his essential nature to become the man that MIB's dead wife described: a man whose wall of good deeds hid the rot that was underneath. Logan is already positioned as the scion of a wealthy entrepreneur whose family (assumedly)…