Please, don't tell me you're using America as an scapegoat for the great depression? What caused the depression is still highly debated among scholars so pick a better excuse. Of course, America is important in world history that is what this film saying you moron. There is a difference between acknowledging America's…

Moron, do you know how history works? It's not simply reduce to "cause and effect". If you to reduce history to that go right ahead but leave all the thinking to the smart people.

Please, don't tell me you're using America as an scapegoat for the great depression? What causes the depression is still highly debated among scholars so pick an better excuse. Of course, America is important in world history that is what this film saying you moron. There is a difference between acknowledging…

"A victorious and prosperous Germany doesn't turn Fascist, no matter how charismatic Hitler is."
No, it Germany turned fascist not just because of Hitler's charisma. But also because he was master of propaganda and was credited for the economic boom among other things. Did you even read that passage?

Uh huh

Uh-huh.
"What seems necessary, therefore, is an examination not of Hitler's personality, but of his popular image – how the German people saw their leader: the 'Hitler Myth'. The 'Hitler Myth' was a double-sided phenomenon. On the one hand, it was a masterly achievement in image-building by the exponents of the new…

Wow, epic fail. Sorry, but it's you and people like you are stupidest c**ts around. Nothing you've said makes any sense and the people who actually agree with your nonsense are even dumber than you. You are just a moron to you think can predict certain events in history would have never happened. There is no possible…

"German annexation of independent nations and persecution of the Jews was the result of very specific events, which involved the US. "

"German annexation of independent nations and persecution of the Jews was the result of very specific events, which involved the US. "

"It is completely ridiculous to say a bunch of different events would all lead to the same specific thing."
It completely ridiculous to claim things happening differently negates human nature. Furthermore, some things happening differently doesn't mean that everything would be different. My God, you're a lunatic. You…

Actually, I believe his knows more about history than you. You have yet to give a credible argument on why it's absurd that Nazis would develop an atomic bomb? Your only argument is that Nazis didn't think they were close to developing an atomic bomb. But all that proves is that didn't have the knowledge for it NOT…

No, clearly you're not thinking about what you're saying. Apparently people don't seem to grasp what Dinesh is saying. Because he never said or implied that America has zero effect on the world affairs. In fact his claiming the exact opposite. What you and others like you are doing is knocking down strawmen. There is…

You do know you don't have to respond right?

Yeah, none of that refutes what he says. You're just grasping at straws and clinging red herrings. If you're going to refute his arguments then stick to the actual argument.

Okay, you know what. I'm sick of these dumb replies. This movie is actually suggesting that US have huge impact on history from 1775 to 1939 and beyond. Not the opposite so I don't know what you're rambling about. So just be quiet and stop making red herrings.

Yeah, none of that refute what Dinesh said. It's seem as though you're grasping at straws and not actually responding to his actual argument.

How is he underselling the importance of the US? His actually doing the exact opposite. You're saying that certain circumstances wouldn't have happened if the US never existed yet you have nothing substantial to back it up.

Yeah, none of that refutes what Dinesh just said.

"Did the U.S. steal Mexico in the Mexican War? No, we retired its debt and gave it back! " “

He's not assuming anything his asking a question. Hypotheticals is not a fallacy, people do it all the time in debates. Are you people really this stupid that "what if" scenarios are invalid because it didn't happen? Unfortunately, these things don't happen until they do.