Have never been to anything like that—sounds super interesting. And of course it would encourage repeat business as people could "choose their own adventure" in different ways.

I wasn't sure what the show wanted us to think about the play, but I thought it seemed like a cool idea.

I completely agree, and I remember thinking the same thing when she told Adam she couldn't be with them when they were in the hospital next to the baby.

That scene at the table, especially after Hannah left, was genuinely laugh-out-loud funny.

Yes, I had a couple girlfriends who were like that. And I am sure they weren't performing for my benefit, as I just don't think they had that acting capacity (Harry and Sally aside), especially for the expressions of genuine mortified embarrassment afterward if there was anyone in earshot. One of them also tended to…

Also, they didn't just come lunging out. They were a little hesitant, but ventured out slowly due to their hunger and smelling blood. Furthermore, they are going to be tempted more by a bloody, incapacitated target than by whatever armed men brought Ramsey in there.

All season I thought this was the best season yet of the best show on TV. But that finale was really underwhelming. S1 and S3 had much better finales (and S2 much worse), so now I'm not sure where this season stacks up.

I thought that was kind of weak, a bit of a retread of stuff we've seen before. I'm tired of those particular spinning wheels.

I didn't get that either. Especially since it's a moot point if they're planning to flee the country!

"Even Tywin Lannister thinks Tarly needs to take it easy."

B+? Pfffft. This is where the show jumps the shark, not with the subsequent episode. Roslin's magical hybrid-baby blood cure was groan-inducing, risible. If you didn't stop watching the show after the Resurrection Ship storyline wrapped up, get out now and try to scrub your brain of this ridiculous turn of events.

I think I probably like the remainder of the series a bit less than you do, but I think my opinion would be the same even if I thought it was…well, let me put it this way.

The rescue was pretty cool, but it doesn't make up for the dreariness of the time we spent there up to that point. And doing the Iraq War allegory with the U.S. as the Cylons, or vice versa? Really? Whatever you think of that war (and I am a Democrat, albeit a Hillary supporter and not a Bernhead), we didn't occupy…

Back atcha.

Ehhh…no. You and I clearly have very different tastes in television.

Do you mean the first half of season 2 is the high point?

Yeah, a lot of people seem to like the New Caprica storyline. I don't understand that at ALL.

I liked this better than the recapper, but either way: STOP.

The rest of the show shouldn't be watched anyway. When I rewatched with my kids a couple years ago (who were too young to watch when it first came out), I stopped after this episode, which marks the end of the show's salad days. If I could "Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" the rest of the episodes out of my own brain,…

Oh, don't get me started on "LOST". It does not have to be either/or. A great show (which I once believed "LOST" was) can be both character-driven and plot-driven. But if "LOST" wanted to just be character-driven, they should have had them all be marooned on the island, and then just depict their personal…