I agree that part of the Hawley problem is that his introduction feels forced due to the number of episodes he's been in, but don't agree with you that he could (or rather, that he should) have a useful place on the show. Hawley and Jenny occupy the exact same narrative niche. They both provide access to mystical…

I totally agree that Katrina fits in better than Hawley. She does at least have a legitimate reason to exist in the plot and has a very useful skill set, unlike Hawley, who seems to be there simply because he's attractive. If I had to choose one character to be banished from the show and never return, I would pick…

I don't know. I mean, I don't have anything against Katrina and I'm trying to keep an open mind about where the story takes her, but ever since the first episode of the first season, her character has seemed a little… untenable to me. I think the problem is that she really kind of exists to make Ichabod unhappy and…

You know, the fact that Grayza seduced a lot of people to get into her current position never bothered me too much. I agree that it is potentially problematic, since it would be easy to assume that because she used sex to advance her career, she must be incompetent or unqualified. However, she's not working in the…

I didn't hate the Peacekeeper Wars but I didn't think it was anywhere near as good as the show. However, I think TPW has a lot in common with the Firefly movie Serenity, and in more ways than they were both created in response to angry fan protests following a sudden cancellation.

This makes me so sad. I literally just found out these reviews had started up again last week and I was looking forward to reading your reviews of the rest of the series :(