This is really the most legit reason I’ve seen for not remaking it with women. I may not necessarily agree with it (actually, I’m completely uninterested in the remake or the original) but this makes a lot more sense than most of the arguments I’ve read for why it shouldn’t be remade.

The North American Meet Institute?

Yay, BACON!

Yeah nah. I’m sure we could cut out all bacon and other delicious meats, cheeses that may be high in fat, dairy in general, alcohol, caffeine, cake, all manner of wonderful but not so great for you things and end up adding an extra few years on at the end.

The North American Meat Institute

My mother’s email title was “Looks like we were right!”. (We = Jewish people.)

Don’t give it that much credit. It doesn’t like that which is popular. Simple. You are popular, MT thinks you don’t deserve it, hence the vitriol. She’s done this to me too. Let’s just say there’s a pattern.

Ignore this person. She hates me too. She just claims a target and then harasses the shit out of them, then goes to other forums to talk shit. It’s really sad.

I feel like you are having trouble making your point, partly because I am having trouble seeing your point. I have one thought and one question , if you don’t mind the late intrusion.

So... are we going to argue who has it worse, or whose narrative is more relevant?

The intent doesn’t really change the victim as it’s not about them.

Ugh, shut up.

You can “think I’m wrong”, but the end logic of what you suggest is that by denying the womanhood of trans women, TERFs are somehow attacking men - and it’s simply not the case. Trans women aren’t men, and attacking trans women is not and can never be misandry for that precise reason. Trans women are women. TERFs…

TERFs aren’t attacking trans women out of a case of mistaken identity, they’re attacking them specifically because of a known facet of their identity. It’s not misandry, it’s transmisogyny.

I am not a transgender woman. No one is claiming that trans and cis women’s experiences are exactly the same. Trans women do face significantly higher rates of sexual assault, murder, and suicide than cis women. Which are issues that feminists generally care about, the sexual assault, murder, and suicide of women.

Thank you so much for taking the time to explain that. And I am, and was, totally sympathetic. I consider myself a feminist and an ally of all oppressed people. Whether or not I can fully grasp their situations, I think all people should be able to be who they are without fear of discrimination or intimidation.

Terf’s are a prime example of why Misandry is no joke

Nobody in their right mind would want to be a woman in this culture.

This kyriarchal idiocy (where everybody has a set of people they “outranks” and are allowed to shit on them) is fucking bullshit, and humanity would be better all around if people like you would stop acting like people living their own damn lives, minding their own damn business, were still somehow all about you, just…