This show has made me completely re-evaluate Hartnett as an actor. I don't know whether being around great actors like Green and Dalton has made him up his game, whether it's the wonderful writing of John Logan, or if he's simply matured as an actor since the days or "Pearl Harbour", but he seems way more interesting…

He's great. If they ever kill him off, I'll probably stop watching. Well, okay,I won't because I love this show, but I'll write a whole load of stuff on the internet about how angry I am. That'll teach John Logan to mess with my feels.

I've watched a lot of horror movies in my time and I've managed to get through almost all of them in mostly in one sitting (and that included "A Serbian Film" - if you know anything about that particular movie, you'll know what sort of stuff I can usually endure) but I actually had to take a break with this episode.…

Agree with all of this. Would I watch a mini-series about Vanessa and the Cutwife living together on the moors, as the latter teaches the former about the dark arts? On the basis of this episode: absolutely.

Somewhat surprised at the grade. This is my favorite episode of the season so far.

Personally, I like the fact that they've kept that aspect of the original character's personality when they could have simply airbrushed it away. Added to that is the fact that some of the scenes and dialogue about Sherlock's struggle against addiction have been so well written that I almost suspect someone on the…

I adore this show's portrayal of Victorian London, from the gothic mansions through to the cholera-infected underworld and the old subway trains. I could seriously drink this stuff up. This show is absolutely filled with visual treats.

I'm absolutely LOVING McCrory here. The witches are a great addition to the show, and I'm looking forward to seeing what they get up to as the show progresses.

I agree that the Vanessa / Monster scene was a definite highlight of both this episode and the season so far.

Must..[CLICK! CLICK!] ..downvote you.. [CLICK! CLICK! CLICK!] ..as much as I can.. [CLICK! CLICK! CLICK!]

I think it's a combination of Sam Richardson's wonderful line delivery and the fact that Richard is like a happy puppy swimming around a pool filled with sharks. His obliviousness, politeness and naivety are so at odds with the sharp-minded cut-throats around him that you can't help but chuckle at him stumbling his…

Same here. At one point whilst watching, a voice in my head said gleefully "This is fucking great!" I was expecting an A- score for this one.

I thought it was Andrew Scott (Moriarty from BBC's "Sherlock") at first.

The third paragraph of this excellent review (great work Kayla, by the way) completely nails why this show works as well as it does. This is one of the best portrayals of love I can remember seeing in a television drama. Most shows seem to falter once they get past the will-they-or-won't-they stage, and the two…

I'll admit that I loved the hell out of her ending during the mid-season finale. Her declaration of love, after months of being so closed in and broken, and Miller's performance as Sherlock heard that declaration, pretty much kicked me straight in the heart.

I miss Kitty. :( I've not enjoyed the second half of the show as much as the first, mainly due to Kitty and what she brought to the dynamic.

Me too. She really makes that character work, and it's a testament that she's still fantastic even buried beneath all of that make-up.

Yeah, Coulson's "I think we've been spending too much time together" followed by looks from Hunter and Fitz evoked the one and only genuine laugh I had during this episode.

Hopefully never.

Disagree totally. McCrory was amazing.