How can you say you lose belief in her the more she talks then still maintain hes abusive? Im honestly perplexed by this position since the accusation comes from her. If her word isnt credible then everything coming from her isnt credible

Her testimony is all over the damn place. Now shes claiming he broke her nose the day before she filmed James Corden. Really? Wheres medical records? How can you scrunch a broken nose? Why was an RN unable to see this bruising and damage to her scalp? Honestly, @ me all you want, but anyone who still believes her is…

Theres a few therapists who give some insight into those tapes on YT. As much as one can at least. I thought they were interesting.

Not even just the tape but her stories and evidence dont hold up to scrutiny. I think the tapes lost her credibility to reasonable people because it exposes her as a liar. Now her stories are increasingly bizarre and dramatic as Depp makes his way refuting what shes already said. Lies to cover up lies. Now shes saying…

Yes abuse IS typically hidden, she previously said his employees stood by and did nothing as he abused her. 

Being wrong on a year is not some monumental blow to her credibility. All of their witnesses were being asked to recall specific events months or even years after the fact to the best of their ability. 

And its not little details shes calling BS on but EVERYTHING. The RN and doctor is wrong about her anxiety, drug/alcohol issues, no polar, anger/rage issues, insecurtity, etc. She so rarely does drugs yet told the RN she was high for 24 hours and threw up but no, wait, she slept for 24hrs and just felt sick. Like wtf?…

I had a pathological liar as a coworker a few years ago. She stated everything from working security for Obama, partying with Michelle, having a nice townhouse with a jacuzzi right outside Quantico for $600, wings she brought in a local pizza places box were homemade, etc etc. You could tell any story and she had her…

She initially said they repeatedly refused to intervene

Her stories become increasingly dramatic as Depp refutes everything. To me, thats a sign of a liar. The human memory isnt an infallible thing but this woman is consistent with it. Take poopgate for example. In her TRO she said Depp was yelling about something that “didnt happen”. When Depp first publicly alleged human…

Keep to her witness statements because her testimony is an absolute shitshow. Its so much worse than what I thought itd be. I cant keep up with the inconsistencies

I think, because this is a high profile case, they NEED him to be guilty. They can take or leave her abusive behavior but they need him to be. So much so that its clouding judgement. Maybe a bit of projection from personal experience as well. However crazy Gone Girl is, this is really looking like it. Except Amber…

His witnesses arent simply character witnesses. They’re testifying to what they have or haven’t seen. I think people arent even open to the possibility that a woman would lie, tbh. The statistics are on Ambers side and”shes crazy and lying” has been thrown out at pretty much all accusers. But...Amber legit sounds like…

I think thats more down to Kate not dealing with media in general. She did say nice things about him years after they split

In the audio he said he “headbutted her on accident”. On the witness stand he said he used the word “headbutt” because thats the word she used and that they bumped foreheads as he was trying to restrain her “haymaker” punches. To me the explanation is plausible as physical contact will be made while trying to defend…

Depp not being abusive to Winona or Vanessa doesnt automatically mean hes innocent of Ambers allegations. But the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. He only drank red wine with Vanessa for 14 years. Got completely sober then he relapsed and within a year or so he does a complete 180 to start beating…

If my parents divorced when I was younger then Id probably have issues from it. But I think we all wouldve been better off in the long run. Its one of those weird things. Barring abuse, no kid wants to see their parents split in the moment. My paternal grandparents split when my dad was maybe 10. He was always so…

Right? Who is going to see what goes on more than PAs and bodyguards? I think its a super dismissive take more because some people seem to *need* Depp to be guilty. His “history of violence” gets talked up as if hes known for bar fights and assault charges. The few “altercations” hes had are at least 5-10yrs apart. Im…

I agree. I talked to someone yesterday  where an RNs notes were being dismissed. Initially it was because she talked to Depp at Ambers bday party so shes bias. An RN is third party, not strictly employed by either Depp or Heard, and has a responsibility to report any sign of abuse. To suggest her credibility is…

I 100% think she lied simply because of how bizarre her “evidence” is. Like the perfect little rectangle over her eye after “Johnny threw a phone”. She also said she was horrifically beaten the day before she filmed James Corden. Its too sketchy. With that said, I do try to keep in mind that unknown evidence comes out…