Now that I think about it, I would love a Hamlet ending. I want to see everybody dead with Heather (the rational one) being the only one left alive and Rebecca telling her "Tell my story!" with her dying breath.

I wouldn't say they were ecstatic. Relieved, maybe. Then sure as hell didn't look like people who have been stuck on that train for who knows how many hourse. Did they all just not go to work that day? Why didn't anyone just MacGyver the door and say "screw it, I'll walk"?

He seduced her while she was his student, that's why she dropped out of his class. That alone should have led to him getting suspended.
That being said, in many cases these rules aren't really taken seriously. Lots of times, the professors not only sleep with their students openly, but later make them their TA's.…

She was an undergrad at that time. Rebecca did say "I dropped out of your class, now we can be together," meaning he had seduced her while she was his student. How she was the only one suffering the consequences is baffling. He should have been suspended.

To be fair, years ago Rebecca did think that going to Law School was going to solve her problems.She believed that gloing after what society defined as success (great education, career) would make her happy. Greg is really not much different.

Music was better in season 1, which is why I'm so happy they got an early renewal. It gives them much more time to think things through and write great songs. Rachel did say on some podcast that some of the songs this season took as little as 20 minutes to write. I'm glad she now has a few months to work on it.

I think the pacing was great in the first half of the season. There was enough character development, some subtle foreshadowing. And then it suddently seemed like they ran out of time and needed to wrap it all up. It did feel kind of abrupt and unearned. Darryl didn't even have a storyline this season, we barely saw…

Well, she did say "Yale, Harvard undergrad," so that made perfect sense to me.

But the Westchester Sperm Machine told Josh that Rebecca was supposed to go to Harvard, but something happened and she chose Yale instead. That would mead she never even started Harvard Law.

I doubt she spend a year at that facility. She was probably only there
for a few months in the summer, so she could go to Yale in the Fall
without missing any time. That's why she never addressed her issues: her mother convinced her they would all go away as soon as she made it career wise. Yale was more important…

Stuck or shut down for an entire day? And everybody just sat there waiting? Nobody made a scene? Nobody went crazy? Nobody just forced open the door and walked out of there? Have these writers ever been to NYC? Or, like, on a train? Ever?

People who write for this showobviously don't know how parenting works. They also don't know how money, jobs and relationships work. They live in their own little bubble.

The writers of this show think sexual harassment is sexy. They don't understand that Duke is not a sexy bad boy, but rather a creep. It's pretty obvious this show is being written for middle aged housewives, and that's what they perceive as romantic: Toby's unsolicited grand gestures, Kevin's long-ass, unnatural…

William lives in Philadelphia. Randall went there to meet him and brought him to New York. Then William would still take secret trips to Philly every day to feed his cat (where's that cat by the way?)
From what I understand, the kids all moved from Pittsburgh to NYC, probably for college. Kevin and Sophie got married…

Nah. The pilot was promising, but the show gets worse every week and the characters, instead of growing layers, and flatter and more one-dimentional every single episode. Not to mention it's sexist and borderline racist. I'm hate-watching at this point, and this isn't even The Affair, which is at least funny to…

Beth is a terribly written character. Wait, she's not even a full character, she's just Randall's wife. That's the only thing the writers gave her, they didn't bother with giving her any type of background. Does she have a job? What does she do all day? What are her aspirations? Why doesn't she have friends of her own…

Damn it, they're in Season 1 and they're already at a point where they can't come up with anything fresh and just rehash old tropes. How is this show going to last for more than one season if it's already obvious they're out of ideas now?

Is the showrunner's sister's whole life based entirely on her being obese? Does it all she ever talks about?

#1. In Justin Hartley's defense, there's not much he can do with the writing he is given. Those speeches are ridiculous, inauthentic and have very little to do with how people actually express themselves. I can get a a regular monologue once in a blue moon, but he gets a couple of those stage-y speeches in every…

Rebecca going on tour would actually be the only good thing about this show in a long time. So far her whole identity is being a wife and a mother. She doesn't even seem to have her own friends. Why is everybody acting like her being a musician is somehow not a job? She's working and touring is a part of it. Maybe her…