I was going to give this a B+, but after close reflection…I'm going to give it an A simply for the fact that stupid Alisha caught a round to the head from a little girl while she should've listened to her girl and got the hell out of there. I can only imagine if there were only others watching who went "OH!!" when it…

Until it's proven otherwise, I believe the kid is alive. We never saw where Beth went, so she could have saved Judith and they made it back in time to catch the last bus out of Dodge.

It's only like the comics in events only, everything else different like character, circumstances and context.

Heh, I guess luck wasn't with either Victor or Charlie Francis this time around.

Also unlikely considering he got ran through the middle of the chest with a sword and apparently shot in the head. Even if Lilly missed the shot, there's no way he would survive the sword through his chest.

The show does indeed stray away from some of the darker moments from the comics. A spoiler example would be The Governor repeatedly raping and torturing Michonne. This lead to her taking an eye, an arm and his testicles. So…yeah, I'd say the show definitely does avoid the extremely darker moments.

While, the baby did die in the comics, it's not entirely implausible that Judith could have survived this one due to the x factor that is Beth. We didn't see her get off the bus and we don't know where she went afterwards, so it is within the realm of possibility that she saved Judith.

Not since Kennedy in season 7 of BtVS has a gay character just strolled into a place and manage to immediately find the only other gay person there and predictably hook up. Although it would've been interesting to have seen Alicia say "Yeah, I like girls too…but you're not my type." Oh well…