Ahh, the opinions of the masses.

So, which branch of the military are you in that requires a sword for combat?

You'll notice that nowhere did I say "if you have never forged, you cannot comment on it." What I said was "I HAVE forged, so I will consider what this guy does forging". Two wildly different statements.

As for the "not a weapon but a replica", if it has an edge and everything we have seen DOES have an edge, it is,…

Nothing as elaborate as a spring blade, but yes. I have primarily forged horseshoes and small, utilitarian blades.

I'll hit em up tomorrow!

As someone who owns a forge and has actually forged items, I kiiiiind of have a decent idea what forging is.

So, yeah, I'll consider it forging.

They are absolutely "properly forged" weapons, as he heats the metal and shapes it. Your argument is fallacious as is calls into being the "no true Scotsman" fallacy.

You really think, in 2013, that people are clamoring for a SWORD they can use in "real combat"?

Really? THAT'S your argument?

God DAMN, I loves me some Franken and Boo Berry. I still need to find Yummy Mummy and Fruit Brute in my area.

Looks like he's just making a statement. So, no.

You said he was popular, as though that were the barometer for a thing. There's plenty of terrible shit that's popular and shouldn't be.

You said he was popular, as though that were the barometer for a thing. There's plenty of terrible shit that's popular and shouldn't be.

I'm really surprised no one in that crowd destroyed his ass for that. Look at his face after he hit her. Look how fucking proud of himself he is.

Might be better to keep it that way in the future, from what we've seen in this thread.

Might be better to keep it that way in the future, from what we've seen in this thread.

Nascar is wildly popular, too. Doesn't make it good.

This. I'm sure I'd have played it had I known it existed.

And of that list, only 2 I care about, and of those 2, only 1 is exclusive to the WiiU. Wonder why people would rather have the PS4 or X1?

Um, you DO know that the guy who wrote that article, William Usher, is employed by Nintendo, yes?

Kind of makes his argument suspicious at best and downright lies at worst.

So many headshots in this post. And yet, the OP will ignore it.