But anyone who's 30 or older and started playing games as a kid

And got eaten by wolves.

It's basically impossible to build consensus on video games, similarly to TV, because of the length of games. If you need to devote dozens of full working weeks to play out all the games on a top 100 list thoroughly in order to form a full opinion, you're going to end up with one or two people tops who are even…

when you've got rape, incest, rape, murder, rape, slavery, rape, and torture

Nothing that has happened to Sansa has been her fault.

Well, everyone still remembers that part of the story. I mean, they act like they don't, but they do.

You expect a show that's forgotten about ~60% of their cast and attendant backstories to bring back a dead person for more flash backs?

Robin's throwing out lines about how she doesn't seem so evil.

I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the reactions might have something to do with the giant plot holes that the writers keep yanking on. The good-guy of the week episode format through the first two seasons brought in way too many characters (yet still strangely, not enough, because apparently every useful…

Yeah, I don't need Game of Thrones style CG to make it believable, but I'd like it if someone in the show runners would recognize that their CG isn't that good and you know, stop emphasizing it toward the start of every episode. Know your weaknesses.

The most stunning discontinuity to me is that down in the forest, where the holly berry apparently blooms at all times of the year, it appears to be the middle of summer, late spring or possibly early fall, but just up a small hill (where you can still see the forest in the background!) it's apparently winter enough…

I commented on the opening shot last night that OUAT has cinematography people who wish they were doing The Lord of the Rings and CGI people who wish they were doing Pinocchio.