It's not really a question of whether there were black knights or black gunslingers. The two archetypes are essentially fantasy and have little to do with really existing historical figures. The point is they are both cliched and mashing them together didn't work. Going with Elba precisely cos he is black and a great…

Idris Elba is a good actor and I can see him working in the role. The gunslinger-cum-Arthurian knight always struck me as a horrible mash up. Both separately are really cliched. Mashing them together didn't work. Having a black actor play this ostensibly white role would immediately change that horrible mash up in…

The writers didn't build her up to be a ''bad ass'', the fanboys did. The writers aren't responsible for the bizarre reactions of people who exhibit the mental age of a 13 year old. That's why it's so hilarious. This was not bad writing, it was the consistent reaction Carol has to any problem: kill. She was a…

I like how you took all those words to get to the point that Carol is a dumbass. Just one minor point: Carol didn't know the Wolf was there until she went down into the basement. Your whole reasoning is false. Her immediate reaction was to try kill him. This shows that when it comes to killing Carol is like a junkie…

I don't get the criticism of people falling, people do fall it's not that bad a thing to happen in the grand litany of bad things that happen. It's certainly not as stupid as some of the stealth Zombie kills. Also wasn't the concussion thing just a ruse to get Morgan to lower his guard so she could go see what he was…

Maybe you should just read through the other responses before posting nonsense. anyway you're a sock puppet so why would I bother refuting you again?

I spent all yesterday refuting it when other people came out with it. you haven't said anything that contradicts anything I said. If you managed to not read anything else I posted, it's shorter to just get to the calling you stupid part. you are also a sock puppet most likely, so theres that as well.

Holy Jesus that wall of text is nonsense, pure nonsense and I can't find any nice way to say that. I'm sorry I'm sick of fools now., good bye.

You can think that, of course, but you are very clearly wrong in that. Last week's statement was unambiguous.

It's not pragmatism, it never was. That's just how people justified it to themselves that they were cheering a woman who enjoys murdering people. If it's pragmatism it's like how Hitler was pragmatic.

Maybe he is not as bad as he is made out to be. Maybe Morgan was right all along. Those scenes were about showing that Carol was desperate to get her fix and that Morgan was not crazy or stupid like the fanboys have been shouting. I'm not surprised it went over everyone's head.

I'm not painting her in anyway. I don't need - like you - to have an emotional connection to characters. I am not a fanboy. I literally don't give a shit about any particular character. I like the show as a whole. Carol turning into a psychopath is brilliant writing, I like this writing. The only way you can…

I understand it perfectly. that's why it upsets the fanboys. The 'practical' argument falls down because this was the least practical thing she could do. Now you're trying desperately to move the goalposts. not working.

What he is doing is not stupid, even if we grant for the sake of argument that the Wolves need to be eradicated, taking prisoners to try turn them/interrogate them is not stupid. Even if you believe Morgan is unduly and naively idealistic, it's still not stupid to take prisoners. What is stupid is the belief that…

I didn't say he was rehabilitated. that's just a stupid thing to try and imply. The mocking tone is not necessary cos I already know where your argument is going and I already know its stupid. sorry about that champ. that's how I see things.

If that's your level of cause and effect, this conversation is terminated. good bye.

The most you can accuse Morgan of is not having the foresight to account for Carol's stupidity.so you don't have much of an argument. He had the situation under control.

Morgan has the Wolf in a purposefully converted basement cell. He is no danger and outside the plot contrivances of TV land it is actually pretty easy to restrain and keep some one locked up.

It was Carol distracting Morgan that allowed the Wolf to pounce. If Carol didn't do that the Wolf would still be tied up in his basement cell.

but they won't kill you cos you will know how to handle it just like you know how to handle a dead body now (in the very unlikely event you have to deal with one that is).