I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. The analogy was about a news organization that didn't get its facts straight. Shots fired from off camera were aren't proof that a specific person fired the shots. I'm aware of how much circumstantial evidence makes its way into newspapers but when you have Snapper Mister…

Here's another factor I thought of. Winn bragged to Cat about having invented the lead dust sprayers. Cat knows Winn doesn't know that many people and suspects (correctly) Guardian is probably someone they both know. Add the fact that James is conveniently missing and James=Guardian.

She needed someone who was capable and whom she could trust. Winn fills those requirements rather nicely.

Agreed. I said when they added Mon-El and M'gann that there were too many characters and while I semi miss her I've been hoping we wouldn't see Mon-El after this season. I wouldn't mind Guardian if they made a few changes like getting rid of the solve-every-problem-by-punching-someone thing. I'm also really tired of a…

The ships must also be fairly small. Based on Kara's silhouette, the portal is maybe 30 feet across and ships were coming through side by side with room to spare so they're maybe the size of mini vans?

Lord help me, I love it. I wonder if Kara has the nerve to be Press Secretary?

Positron cannon. What the rest of us would call a particle beam weapon. At least this review got it right. Another review called it a "positron laser," LOL.

Do you remember the Dan Rather controversy from 2004? CBS News received documents that purported to show President George W. Bush had disobeyed orders while in the National Guard, and had used family connections to cover up that and other misconduct. CBS ran the story with Rather as the anchor. The documents were…

She'd get my vote. How old is she supposed to be in the series? The Constitution says 35 is the minimum age. Lex became President in the comics at one point. Maybe Lena and Cat:
Luthor/Grant 2020!

With Guardian especially there was video of someone shooting a criminal. It wasn't known whether they were the only people around or not, as it happened they weren't. Snapper reported based on incomplete information. The video of Lena was taken at LCorp.

I've been posting about the President being an alien all season. I'm withholding judgment until I see how or if they deal with the President being ineligible. It may be a plot point going forward for next season. If they ignore it I'm going to be very disappointed.

Lena discovered "Mike" (Mon-El) was an alien last episode when he came crashing through the roof of her lab with Supergirl and J'onn, and called Rhea "Mother." I wonder what she thinks of Kara dating an alien?

Considering the consequences of Mon-El not going along with Rhea I think it's a bit unrealistic to expect him to do much of anything other than bide his time.

1. I never said you do (I'm assuming you're black?)
2. Cat got a quick glimpse of his eyes and right away she recognizes him?
3. Presumably you've never heard of hyperbole: 1. obvious and intentional exaggeration. 2. an extravagant statement or figure of speech not intended to be taken literally, as “to wait an…

It's been brought up. I don't know how they'll handle it. I'd like to think it will be addressed, maybe Marsdin will be impeached. It would give CADMUS an excuse to come out of the woodwork as a legitimate organization.

It was established in the Pilot that Winn made her costume out of fairly ordinary materials. He made a reference to "superpolymers" or some such and James mentioned that "this cape won't shred" when he gave her Clark's baby blanket. But basically her costume is supposed to be a notch above cosplay stuff and yet we…

Yeah, that's another lame leftover from last season. Superman could be "off world" but Alex told Supergirl she wouldn't be able to "generate thrust" outside the atmosphere. Which reminds me, last episode Supergirl, J'onn and Mon-el all came crashing through the ceiling of Lena's lab. Since Mon-El can't fly (although…

Me too. To be honest, I was unfamiliar with the term until someone called me one as a put down.

Their version of Jesus wasn't one.

Agreed. One of Supergirl's defining traits is that she never gives up on anyone.