Er, I'm not Jed either but what he said was perfectly valid?

Well, it WAS a trial!

Do you mean starts shooting Monday, or starts airing? I thought it was a summer show.

To be fair, she isn't exactly writing and directing every episode of this show without a writers room. She's got older people on the payroll, and I doubt she is rewriting the scripts from the older people to make it more artificial or less deep. While I agree with your ultimate point that when the show tries to…

While every single word in your post is true, the point I think Katherine Pryde was taking issue with is the idea that "[a] fair number of posters here and elsewhere feel that this is one of them." They either need better descriptors to distinguish between shows they do not like, explain their opinion better, or…