You are right about that.
I don't mind flaws in works of art and even see them as a good sign if they are the right kind of flaws; flaws made by artistic decisions of one person with the vision.
A lot of great directors have weird 'mistakes' in their work because their art is driven by emotional impulses and they fall…

I watched it again and saw it as her suffering a mental illness and her husband is just an author that she fell in love with.
Maybe last episode was them writing their new book.
Audrey helps him write them and she is the star of the books.
The book series take place in the past when people used rotary phones.
The whole…

Laura described James as sickly sweet. Laura saw James the same way a lot of viewers do.
I don't think James would be able to play Bobby.
He has a face that isn't a menacing guy's and he has this loner vibe. Bobby had to act bit menacing like a bully but not too menacing. He would bounce around laughing and barking like…

I have yet to see Harry Potter but I remember my kids having those jelly bean candies. People like to do such things sometimes. I once had a manager that would eat bugs whenever someone dared him to.
And I actually used to pretend my soup was vomit and I was forced to eat it. We had to do such things before computers…

Thanks for the explanation. I think I am just too far from the mainstream. I watch old Busbey Berkley musicals and like the music. Lynch Badalamenti music is maybe a little like thirties music sometimes. Songs like, "I only have eyes for you," would be considered absurd I suppose nowadays but I have a hard time…

Like Turnip ice cream… or pretending they are eating vomit when they eat soup.

I don't mean everybody that understands fine art would like him at all.

I was wrong. I thought the cup just disappeared because it was momentarily obscured by his right hand.
If you ever have a bizarre real life experience like that, People will say you never saw it.
I have a certain number of bizarre unexplainable incidents in my life. When ever I've told people about them, I can tell…

I watched it again and I think you are right. I didn't want to believe it because it is just too small. This kind of thing can drive a viewer crazy. We're going to be looking for tiny things now. I guess that's fine. Lynch's work 'plays' with mental illness sometimes. Ed probably saw that glitch but doesn't make much…

I'm saying it looks weird but there is a simple explanation why it isn't.
It's pretty tiny. maybe my eyes aren't good enough to see it, by why would he communicate a message that is too hard to see. I don't know where he's done that elsewhere…

If he lifted the cup up and his hand was in front, it would have disappeared and reappeared momentarily.
I resist this idea because people look for hidden things to an absurd degree.
Lynch is usually trying to get an effect rather than hiding it.
Old disappointed Ed burning his love letter is enough drama to legitimize…

He is evil Coop's servant in the Black Lodge for eternity (possibly) now.
That's pretty bad.

Mike knows the rules and he told Cooper that he can wake up. he wouldn't say , "wake up," if he needed evil Coop's insides.
Jeffries wanted Bob. That is what is inside of him and what the dirty men took out of evil Cooper after he was shot.

Look at the review for the episode by the A.v. Club. It astounds me too. I think younger people think pre-British invasion music is cheesy.
In the nineties we didn't think it was cheesy. Most people liked fifties music. Fonzie from Happy days was the hero when we were little.
I wish people could open their minds and…

I read an interview where Isabella Rossellini said she can't sing so they got her to sing it numerous times and cut and pasted the pieces together to get a good version.
In spite of her lack of singing ability, her acting ability pulls it off because her singing had such a haunting mood.

Michael Ontkean wouldn't come back. It is a narrative necessity.

I don't think Lynch thinks at all about the people watching the show.
Most artists do their work for their own pleasure.
Why would he wreck his art?
The 'James has always been cool moment," might be them talking to the audience or it might just be another one of those occasionally awkward pieces of dialogue from Lynch.…

Yeah. It's him lifting the cup in front of him. Don't you just see an object move?

Or maybe moved to Hollywood, became an actress, got older and abused her face with plastic surgery. She was hard to watch in this movie she made a few years ago. Her face would sag. I felt bad for her.
Her face would've aged nicely.

The one I found creepy as a kid was when the class would sing 'shortening bread.' There was a kid in the bed that was dead!
"Three little children lying in the bed
two was sick and the other was dead.
call for the doctor and what he said,
Feed those little ones shortening bread."
Why would there be a dead kid in the bed?
Sou…