darlingofthecityfathers--disqus
darlingofthecityfathers
darlingofthecityfathers--disqus

And I have a suspicion that's precisely where she lost AVC

Nah, it just looks that way because you're so fucking dumb.

All I can really say is I think that's an unhelpfully broad description that doesn't give us much insight into why Tyrion killed Shae when there are other very good reasons.

Look you you say "no need to get personal" and then say shit like "does it hurt my feelings less" and previously implied I don't read critically or ambitiously because I'm disagreeing with you. We can go down the road of insults if you want to but it undermines everything else you say.
To the points at hand you

You don't know what happened behind the scenes with Shae and the Lannisters you're making it almost canon to fit with your theory, it's weak reasoning. Fact is if Bronn had betrayed Tyrion in the way Shae did - she professed to love him and as you say yourself want more from him but she betrayed him and not just with

That's a mighty fine attempt to deflect from the simple fact that Tyrion doesn't kill Shae because he hates women. That's it. I've engaged with your other points about the books and agreed with much of it, just because I don't view them solely through a feminist lens it doesn't mean I haven't close-read the books.

You mentioned women not Sean C, I can't believe you're so ignorant that you don't understand the difference between a man castrated before puberty and a woman. I mean my first post was in sarky jest to an ill thought out post by you but your responses indicate you're not smart enough to grasp the differences. Wow.

"Hormonalist" haha, mate you can't even bring yourself to say it's sexist now. My simple statement merely points out the flaw in your reasoning and by downgrading from sexist to "hormonalist" (like that's a well accepted thing) you've basically admitted it.

Shallow view of love and relationships isn't misogyny.
Bronn said he didn't want to die, Shae betrayed him, Tyrion has no idea whats shes doing and even if she is lying he knows she's twisting the knife with her words and again, still doesn't mean he hates women.

He kills her because she betrayed him and got him sentenced to death, not because he hates women.

Ok yeh, I agree the society is sexist and it leads to an horrific amount of misogyny and Tyrion is definitely as sexist as everyone else really, including the women, I don't think he needs to be singled out for it though, the show definitely makes concessions to modern values in this storyline and it definitely

Ah cool, thanks very much. Very interesting.

Ah yes as I feared, you screamed sexism before thinking it through and then got sarky once I pointed this out, oh well, perhaps you'll think a little harder next time.

And the reason for the snark would be?

His entire circle is for pay because he can't trust anyone. He's self absorbed at times, but then I would think anyone with his particular issues is likely to be. On the Lollys front I don't think he's worse than anyone else, Shae is similarly dismissive of her, but this doesn't indicate that Tyrion hates women. Now

Oh I agree they did it to make the sexual politics more palatable for this day and age of course. Though he's not a misogynist, or perhaps more accurately, he wasn't until she betrayed him.

Right I know exactly where you are coming from, I'm just saying what FCH surmised and he went on to say it was based on what he'd heard from the crew. The speed wasn't the issue according to FCH it was the reasoning behind a lot of the plot points.

Yeh I'm not agreeing with the criticism or with Hulk, I'm simply repeating what he says, I asked him about on badass digest and he said he based his reading on things he's heard from the crew.

That section plays out like a paedophile's dream of how to seduce a child/young teenager. The show simply dispenses with the bullshit raitonalisations and makes it a rape scene. That's a marked improvement to me.

They don't actually work in the industry, write 10,000 word columns about James Bond or publish screenwriting books so your "point" is basically irrelevant.