mine:

i'm totally with you here, though i could do without SFAND, actually, along with ballad of big. but down and out, undertow, snowbound, burning rope, deep in the motherlode, many too many and follow you follow me are all terrific, particularly those first 4 (which ballad of big totally fucks up the flow of). don't get…

this.

that song is fucking incredible.

yeah, because if the suite was side one, anything that could have made up side two would have been terribly anticlimactic. that said, i love duke just as it is. and no, alone tonight (which is, apparently, very poorly thought of in genesis fan circles, but which i love) wasn't a single…the singles were…

i actually was a sucker for reo when they blew up in '81, but what you're saying, musically, is inane and wrong.

yeah, i think the idea that sussudio was the proverbial straw with phil is a revisionist argument, or at least a hipster one. more apt candidates for "the song that phil collins sold out with" would be one more night, don't lose my number, or even easy lover. but even that era, in general, while certainly a shock to…

i dig everything you said here, except: where is the "pedophile' bit in thru these walls?

take me home isn't close to being his biggest solo hit (sussudio, one more night, don't lose my number, against all odds, easy lover, separate lives, another day in paradise, i wish it would rain down, do you remember?, a groovy kind of love, two hearts, and something happened on the way to heaven were all more…

i could do without half of s/t, but duke and abacab are great.

one of the only decent things on IT.

the live versions are way worse. collins hams the fuck out of it. this is, like, '86-on i'm talking.

bees are on the what now?

i know what you mean. i'm 40 and it seems my favorite record should be dylan (who i like) or prince (who i love) or r.e.m. (more love)…but mcis is still the most astounding and all-encompassing document of rock music. that I've ever heard.

i know what you mean. i'm 40 and it seems my favorite record should be dylan (who i like) or prince (who i love) or r.e.m. (more love)…but mcis is still the most astounding and all-encompassing document of rock music. that I've ever heard.

that you include tales of a scorched earth but delete thru the eyes of ruby shows you don't get this album.

that you include tales of a scorched earth but delete thru the eyes of ruby shows you don't get this album.

brutally awful, but almost all of the rest of judas 0 is fucking amazing.

brutally awful, but almost all of the rest of judas 0 is fucking amazing.

i know every syllable.