That ending would have made for a perfect season 2 finale. Loved it! I finally got to yell WHAT?! at my TV again and remembered the gleeful dumbfoundedness (is that a word?) I felt by the time we heard sympathy for the devil on this show the first time. I'm curious to see how Sleepy Hollow will look when they get back…

Seriously, that was absolutely ridiculous. I agree with Zack- having her turn evil and away from Ichabod could have been an interesting development had it been written organically throughout the season. Maybe she didn't feel Ichabod wanted to understand how out of place she felt, so she turned to witchcraft, or…

Wow, they got me with the ring! First when they showed it was Sam's wedding ring and then when police arrested Nate. I actually yelled at my screen then. Surprised Michaela didn't die of a heart attack when news reports said they'd found a ring, haha. But that of course just means that hers is still out there… I don't…

Absolutely LOVED this episode! Best one in quite a while.

She doesn't even have to have it registered. Police can just show it to the media in an attempt to have them help find the owner of that ring. Even if none of her (ex) in-laws sees it, someone is bound to remember that that huge rock belongs to her.

Great, now I am crying again. And I was just starting to get over it. Thanks.

Someone's going to die this season and not come back, the creators said. Here's my hope: they use the remaining three eps or so to make Katrina's turn to the dark side interesting and believable, have Ichabod and Abbie find out in the finale and then have a big battle where she saves them from some other baddie at the…

This is what I'm talking about, Sleepy Hollow! I thought this was a great episode and I even felt something other than annoyance when Katrina was on screen. Sure, the darkness thing that was introduced only last week with her pretending that everything was fine with Irving (that's how I've decided to read it) came out…

Best episode in a long time! It reminded me of season 1 highs.

I 100 percent agree!

I thought this episode was pretty great: Lots of screentime for Abby and Ichabod TOGETHER, hardly any Katrina and a couple of scenes for Jenny as well. I had fun watching Sleepy Hollow for the first time in a while. Bonus: LOVED the karaoke!

I got the impression that he was pretty honest about it, too. He saw how devastated she was and for once decided not to be an a** after everything they went through. Great moment!

Smart kid, that Amber.

This is getting crazy- we seem to be watching this show almost simultaneously, lol. Also, I had to cover my eyes when Adam was walking down the street wearing that… whatever it was. That to me was way worse than the nurse.

I still cannot believe ABC canceled Trophy Wife! Such a great show that needed a better slot and more promo. Everyone I talked to who actually watched it really liked it.

So glad someone else is reading this recap and the comments now, three years later. I'm bingewatching this show right now and checking out the reviews every couple of episodes to see what people thought when it aired. I love this show! And yeah, that scene with Max was pretty sad.