@getlefty: Oh, I know. But I don't back down to someone who's pointing a gun at me. He gots to be got.

@Shinta: "strike the snake at its head, it will strike you with its tail. If you don't like Backbreaker, you're gay."

@getlefty: No, although I find it annoying that crouching will sometimes cause me to fail a mission, and sometimes after completing a side mission successfully I'll get a wanted level and a damn lawman shooting me for no reason. Then I have to go and kill him, which ups my bounty.

@Nethlem: At the very least, they should give you 20 seconds to get out of the water, while your health slowly drains. That way they can keep the water as a border but also protect you from making stupid mistakes.

@kathartik: No - it said the code was invalid.

@kathartik: My golden guns code wouldn't work either.

@ObeseLLama: Hmm...I didn't feel like spending 10 minutes finding flowers, so I ventilated the old man at point-blank range. What's the outcome of this mission? I figured it was that the old woman was dead or something.

@DragonTHC: Grand Theft Boat

@Nethlem: That's not really true. You can go through water as long as it's ankle deep or by the shore. anything deep you get sucked in and die. But I've ridden/walked through a number of small ponds.

@creamed_corn: That made me laugh. holy crap.

@Twanzio: The ironic thing about that is, even after you've killed everyone in the town, you'll tell the nearest hooker "I'm a married man!"

@Deanb: Yeah, I've failed missions because I crouched, and apparently crouching means I've 'terrorized the citizens.'

@06RallyBlue: That's not the PS3. The PS3 doesn't have A, B, or Y buttons.

@Shinta: It's funny, I love this game, didn't like GTA IV, and absolutely hated Oblivion. to each his own, I guess.

It's fun as hell, though I have to say, not as good as Just Cause 2 (in my opinion) overall. The voice acting in RDR is way better, but I'd rather the lasso be more like the grapple hook in JC2. How awesome would it be to lasso two people together? It also drives me crazy when you see axes or pitchforks or hammers…

@spannu: Yeah, I know. I was trying to be funny.

@creamed_corn: Besides the fact that it was written by a lawyer with a hard-on for flowery 18th century prose.