Yeah I read something else last night that hit the nail on the head for me, at the end of the episode Jake and Holt never actually apologized. I think that's what is giving me the bad aftertaste on this ep.

Amy has always hated Halloween, and might still hate most parts of it. I assume that's why the odd costume choice.

I've always wondered if her response was improv

Not if there was a comprehensive set of rules and it was all laid out first. Amy loves rules more than Holt or Jake.

I keep going back and forth on this. I really didn't like them being mean to her. I also find it weird that Jake decided to bust out ILY and proposals just for this bet/heist. That was really crappy. But at the same time, were I Jake or Holt, I would have been suspicious of her as well. I thought the episode was good…

True, but Gina rarely helps Jake with stuff, whereas she helps Holt every day. It's literally her job.

The final scene in the episode was so terrifyingly funny."Kiss from my bro, kiss from my boo" I never felt more in tune with Gina than in that moment because how could you not be horrified?

All the things that you hate about Halloween are what make it the best! The big kids egg you, and you and your friends run away TOGETHER

Does Lena Headey have an eyepatch? Sold.

I am also surprised how much I am enjoying this show. I've given up on the Grinder, but this show is very sweet and simple and easy to watch. I'm enjoying Stamos and Paget Brewster a lot.

"I don't like comedy"

I thought Smash's number was awful. It perfectly encapsulates white people trying to do a Hindi filmy song and making it super boring. At least this one was funny.

Not the best music for sure. It was straight up hilarious though. I wasn't expecting the bluntness so I was laughing my face off.

I loved his eyeroll at Amy asking "So no passed hors d'oeuvres?"

It really doesn't matter how much time passes on this show, but when he said that + the month between the start and end of the ep just means Jake and Amy have been dating a LOT longer than I thought. I think they've passed Jake/Sophia now. Also they've been putting up with the Vulture for a lot longer…..which is…

I could never review this show because I'd just end up making a list of quotes. This show is so quotable! So even if they are super late, thanks for reviewing and sorry about your dog LaToya

Lol not only slept with her, lost his virginity. "It was very fast" Boyle: "Nice!"

SO HAPPY HOLT IS BACK. Also I laughed for a really long time at Amy and Rosa's faces when they were listening to the Vulture talk about his brother's widow. "Just…..go". Also, " NO Pay your bill! Who raised you?"

I loved that. It pretty much encapsulates why Jake and Amy work as a couple and how they are both total weirdos.

They've done fart jokes already, as the aftermath of Terry going on a sympathy diet for his wife. Its the ep with Amy eating the hamburgers and looking like an adorable chipmunk….see ScottyEnn's icon.