fair enough. I really loved the way those passing references and vague images were done though. And for the record, even in those 90 seconds I think it did capture quite a bit of the essence of the original.

that's a lot of insight you've gotten from what was a 90 second mock trailer. It looks AWESOME in my opinion, and I want to see this movie made (and made well, obviously)

I was totally going to stick the one of her and the strategically-placed whipped cream in my foot locker, until I remembered I don't have a foot locker.

whoops my bad! It was your explanation of why it had made your heart hateful and black. And now for some reason I can't change the link. So here it is

Pleasure! Thanks for the sentiment

I understand. Don't be sorry. You were the one making a considered point, I was the one being a smartarse.

Did anyone bring up Elementary?

Life's too short to worry about bad TV!

Oh most of the bad stuff makes it here as well!

That we do comrade.
Actually I'm quite enjoying myself here. It's as if the Elementary vs Sherlock debate has been officially sanctioned!

It's as if Sherlock's story is being told from Watson's point of view! Nice.

phrasing!

The long American TV season can overstay its welcome by comparison.

when you grow up.

"The BBC Sherlock is all show and stunts". I think I was burning out by the time I got to that. It's a lot more than that, it can be very funny at times, it's a good show in its own right etc. etc. My point was that compared to Elementary, it is more like what many would (often unfairly) traditionally associate with…

Totally. The benefit of having so many episodes to truly examine a classic character and how he would cope in today's world. When there's "so much more noise"

"Sometimes your (AV Club) reviews are perfect, sometimes they seem to be made expressely to create arguments and to be "different" from the others"

"in order to reach an America audience it had to be boxed into a formula and incredibly detached from a rich canon."

I know you do, I see where you're coming from and I understand. Comment wasn't aimed at you, just got frustrated.

Beautiful observation