It really didn't, and I don't get this insistence that it did. I don't care if Liz Lemon has a boyfriend or a baby, and I don't care if Alec Baldwin has a charicature for a wife. I liked this show when it was about producing another show. Or when Kenneth made me laugh and not change the channel. Or when it still had…

I love Breaking Bad but prefer Mad Men. Am I not welcome here anymore?

I thought the same thing. I would have said "huh?" if not for my fetish for women in purple clothing stealing spoons.

Eh, Community got the edge last year. They're just trying to avoid Civil War.

Best reviews that are not reviews but summaries of what I just watched: The Simpsons.
Best reviews that try too hard to unravel the philosophical mysteries of life rather than dwell on what makes the funniest cartoon ever so funny: The Simpsons.

I'm totally with you. I love Community, Parks and Rec, Louie… hell, I freakin' love H. Jon Benjamin. But I always get a few chuckles out of Archer the way I would really any Adult Swim cartoon and not a lot more. And I love Jessica Walter's character. And I love Krieger. And Pam. So why don't I laugh more? Really all…

Didn't they also just publish a pretty good piece about how Colbert Report is the better of the two? Colbert will always be 1 in my book just for combining the couple of William H. Macy and Felicity Huffman into Filliam H. Muffman.

And for those ready with their "Magnitude is the Disco Stu of Community" responses, you are wrong.

Your top 4 are correct and for that I give you great praise. But you accidentally put Magnitude in the wrong list.

Oh, I believe it. Still genuinely don't trust VanDerWerff. He comes from a town of secrets.

Reading anonymous people listing the same shows in slightly different orders is amazingly not fun, I just realized.

Thanks for confirming that, I don't trust that VanDerWerff

Caster Troy's #1

The "Adam Richmond is Getting Too God Damned Lazy and/or Near Death to Keep Doing This Shit Award:" Man Vs. Food Nation.

by critical darling i meant ratings darling. Critics don't like walking dead. America does.

I'm still convinced that AMC only unveiled Hell on Wheels and The Killing to keep the hate-bus away from their critical darling Walking Dead. Even though Walking Dead is comparably miles ahead of those shows, it's still worth the effort.

In all fairness, I do find it funny that RuPaul's Drag Race still beat The Office. But okay, I'm done now.

Claire….

Claire… I mean… I don't want to be that guy but… oh man… Claire… your list… ohh… Claire. …..Claire….

Todd I just like that there are at least 51 shows you watched and liked this year. I'm nicknaming you Herby. (Herby is the name of my goldfish that lives in front of my TV and never moves.)