This is one of my favorite songs of all time, and I can't believe I'm reading an AV Club article dedicated to it.

Season 3 is the last season of consistently quality television, but season 4 is worth the watch for a few great episodes. The only reason to watch any more is for completion's sake; I've never seen such a discrepancy in creativity between seasons of television as the first third and the last two thirds of The Office.…

Finn in the mirror of this episode is Finn Mertens from the season finale. Woah.

Finn in the mirror of this episode is Finn Mertens from the season finale. Woah.

So, Bill Cypher refers to Dipper, Mabel, and Soos as Tree, Shooting Star, and Question Mark respectively.  Those three symbols appear on the glowing circle that he disappeared into.  Can I count on the TV Club to help me fill in the rest of the spots?

I'm pretty sure that you did this on purpose, but I absolutely love that "A Second…" sold better than "Me Hitting You", even though "A Second…" is at #2, which would imply that "A Second…" came out before "Me Hitting You".

This is the most positive C- review I've ever read.

I don't usually read the reviews for SNL, but this A- review sounds like a C- from any other show.

I can accept that, but I can't understand it.  No matter how anyone has phrased it, I simply don't understand what I'm missing; I stayed away from reviews until I was able to watch it on Hulu, and I came here expecting that everyone would be overjoyed by this episode.  Although again, I won't accept "lazy pop culture…

I feel like I'm the only one feeling waves of relief upon seeing this episode.  Everyone keeps saying that this one has too many pop culture references that are just there, but outside of the Hunger Games thing (which, thank God, didn't actually end up being a parody), I can't even think of any other pop culture…

I sometimes feel that way, but I loved when Tom made a "Lord of the Rings" joke at Ben, who then replied, "I actually wasn't a fan of Peter Jackson's interpretation, so you can stick that back in your pocket."  He's slightly non-conformist… here's hoping there's never a freaking Doctor Who reference.

I sometimes feel that way, but I loved when Tom made a "Lord of the Rings" joke at Ben, who then replied, "I actually wasn't a fan of Peter Jackson's interpretation, so you can stick that back in your pocket."  He's slightly non-conformist… here's hoping there's never a freaking Doctor Who reference.

I'm going to steal that. That's mine meow.

I'm going to steal that. That's mine meow.

My sister pointed out that she doesn't think BMO identified the note-writer as Lorraine because it was written in lipstick, but because it was written in "chickenscratch".

My sister pointed out that she doesn't think BMO identified the note-writer as Lorraine because it was written in lipstick, but because it was written in "chickenscratch".