I agree more with Kumagoro about the proposal than most of the P&R fans, but at the same time, I thought the rest of episode was pretty solid, so I also agree with Gauephat that the criticism here has been crazy exaggerated.

FUCK DAVID FINCHER

I fundamentally disagree, but I can see your point of view.  From my point of view, I don't see Katniss's survival as a literary misstep and hence the reasons for the sequels felt immediately obvious - To explore the ramifications of Katniss's actions and how that might lead to revolution.  Collins herself expressed…

111,111 is child's play.  1,111,111 is the real magical moment.

1.1) Again, I don't agree with your course of action, so the point is moot as to whether that particular event signifies competence or incompetence.  But I do think you're asking a bit much of the competitors.  They're children - Some are trained to fight, but not necessarily to think.  So if they're not perfect…

Agreement rating: Ranges from 0 (total disagreement) to +1.0 (total agreement); 0.58 indicates agreement within one letter grade, 0.30 is two letter grade's worth, and 0.14 is three letter grade's worth

1) Well, this is really a bunch of (likely uninformed) opinions about a ridiculous and hypothetical situation.  On its own, it seems like such a small detail that I don't think it should really affect the overall quality of the movie, but you could say that it belongs with complaint #2.

The black guy is cool, but I don't watch the show for him.  I watch it for all of them together.  ARGH

Well, you did say you were trying grade more harshly.  BUT YOU'VE GONE TOO FAR THE OTHER WAY.

There are logical issues inherent in any scifi movie based on a gimmick, but I think you just have to turn off that switch.  Still, I'd have to argue against the points you listed:

What is up with people being fans of more than one team in the same league?  This is unacceptable.  You should love one team and have varying levels of hate for all the others.

Well it's better than one of my neighbors, who apparently has Tourette's or something and shouts fucking obscenities at the top of his lungs every other day.

So…do you have hurricane insurance?

Whoa, you guys are pretty harsh on it.  I liked it a lot myself.  What'd you guys hate about it?

What the fuck?!  I didn't know that!  FUCK

What're you, 90?  Adults are generally more creative than kids, who just wear whatever shitty stereotype they've asked their parents to buy at a local pharmacy store because of some commercial during their favorite cartoons.

I actually like it myself.  It may bear absolutely no resemblance to the comics, but it's essentially Batman-lite.

I wonder if this is the Lakers fault.  By getting Dwight Howard, they might've felt like they had to keep Perkins.  And they couldn't keep paying Perkins and Harden.

*a door closes*

Era rankings (best to worst): 2012, near-future, 1931, distant future, 1975, 1850