avclub-a2ba14d750c9b9ac5bcf045365fa9a08--disqus
robownage
avclub-a2ba14d750c9b9ac5bcf045365fa9a08--disqus

Thought it was a surprisingly solid effort. This show hasn't been great for years, but if you take "Farhampton" for what it was, then it was pretty entertaining. Had some pretty good laughs (Quinn being in the room was my favourite moment), and they did the drama just right as well.

Did anyone else feel like CeCe stole her look from Jadzia Dax?

Did anyone else feel like CeCe stole her look from Jadzia Dax?

Loved most of the music. Although I doubt I'll ever believe these kids are clever enough to come up with these fantastic mash ups on the fly.

Loved most of the music. Although I doubt I'll ever believe these kids are clever enough to come up with these fantastic mash ups on the fly.

I quite enjoyed the pilot, to be honest. Do I think this show is going to make it to season 2? Not really, but I reckon it'll probably make for a decent ride along the way.

I quite enjoyed the pilot, to be honest. Do I think this show is going to make it to season 2? Not really, but I reckon it'll probably make for a decent ride along the way.

I actually felt that was the show's best episode in a long time. The NYADA stuff was great (I didn't have the same issues with the Kate Hudson character), and while a lot of the McKinley stuff was a bit off, it still resonated with me emotionally (especially the Burt scene - it's a shame O'Malley has only ever once

I actually felt that was the show's best episode in a long time. The NYADA stuff was great (I didn't have the same issues with the Kate Hudson character), and while a lot of the McKinley stuff was a bit off, it still resonated with me emotionally (especially the Burt scene - it's a shame O'Malley has only ever once

I never really tried out the show last year, but adding Britney pushed me to watch this. She's doing okay for now, but I'm interested to see how someone who needs her own set of handlers is going to deal with mentoring people.

I never really tried out the show last year, but adding Britney pushed me to watch this. She's doing okay for now, but I'm interested to see how someone who needs her own set of handlers is going to deal with mentoring people.

It's funny, because if you asked me to name gay characters on television, I'm not even sure I would come up with Max (despite "Happy Endings" being one of my favourite shows on the air right now). He's one of the few gay TV characters whose sexuality seems to have absolutely no bearing on how he's portrayed. I mean,

It's funny, because if you asked me to name gay characters on television, I'm not even sure I would come up with Max (despite "Happy Endings" being one of my favourite shows on the air right now). He's one of the few gay TV characters whose sexuality seems to have absolutely no bearing on how he's portrayed. I mean,

Looking at Ryan Murphy's track record, at this point if I were a TV exec I'd be saying "Thank you Mr Murphy for your ideas, and we will definitely give you Creator credit, but we're going to put someone actually capable of running a show on a day-to-day basis in charge."

Looking at Ryan Murphy's track record, at this point if I were a TV exec I'd be saying "Thank you Mr Murphy for your ideas, and we will definitely give you Creator credit, but we're going to put someone actually capable of running a show on a day-to-day basis in charge."

That's the one!

That's the one!

Ya, I didn't get the reference either.

Ya, I didn't get the reference either.

Not convinced about the new format. I miss the drama of the judges' table and the scoring is just as arbitrary as ever. I don't mind the viewers' comments, but the YouTube videos are plainly ridiculous - hoping they get phased out. And the scoring really kills a lot of the excitement in general, making it a little too