Good stuff here, certainly one of the better episodes of this show in some time but it was so god damn erratic. Granted that was intentional with all the drug hallucinations but it still feels a little lazy. Maybe this is all backtracked next week because I find it impossible to believe Don will pass up the biggest…

Sam is the dumbest motherfucker alive! He has a piece of metal that can actually kill the zombies and he leaves it behind?!?!

We can only hope so. One of the best episodes this year featured Casitel on a mission with Sam and Dean. Fucking hilarious.

I can't see how every angel is mortal now. Castiel had get his grace removed and no way Metatron did that to every angel. Also, when falling they still had their wings.

That would have been fun. He might get some big kills next year.

Great point about Sam getting power from the trials. Hadn't considered that. Also, he said that he felt like he was cleansing himself from the trials. Stripping away all his sin….maybe he would become super powerful or as others suggested an angel himself. I never trusted Naomi and I still don't. She was probably…

It's like Phil watches a completely different show than me. It is an advantage they don't waste time with multiple story lines. No wasted effort here. The last 2 episodes were so action packed and full of side plots you need to re-watch them just to catch it all.  Sure some stuff could have used more explanation but…

Yeah Phil's review are utterly pointless. Meanwhile Arrow, cheesy and incoherent as hell (I like Arrow), gets a fucking perfect A rating. New reviewer please!

CARRY ON!

Great point nathaliad, they must have a willing vessel. But Castiel took over the body of a true believer so I bet that's what happens here.

Funny but not their best work. Weak point for the season. Gus excels at physical comedy which there wasn't enough of here.

AVClub would create a new letter in the alphabet so Kevin could grade it higher than A+.

Completely agree. Flashbacks are incredible. Wish they would dedicate entire episodes to them like when Ollie got seriously injured.

I think he was telling the truth. He didn't kill Malcolm.

Great episode. A lot of fun. The final fight between Ollie And Malcolm was great. Hopefully he comes back even more vengeful next season. Didn't Ollie tell Tommy he didn't kill him? Then Tommy said thanks. The double machines was incredible. Malcom/Dark Archer should have been a much bigger character.

This might be the funniest episode of the season. I can't remember laughing this hard in a while.

"memories that you don’t need to refresh by pulling DVDs off the shelf or
consulting the show’s Wiki page? If you do, you should probably be writing these things, instead of me." is the smartest, most accurate thing Phil has ever written about Supernatural.

How can Tommy possibly take over with zero training whatsoever? Granted it's utterly ridiculous but I can buy the skills of Malcolm and Ollie because they trained extensively for years. Malcolm probably way more than 5 years. If Tommy takes over that would be pretty stupid. Unless they show him vanish for years and…

I like this show but jesus christ CW!! Tommy just happens to pay a visit and look in the window at the EXACT moment they're about to fuck. So, so stupid. Show needs to be better than that.

Not without his father in law. Pete's definitely falling behind now.