Haha another problem with that episode. Them pretending to be rich people at a fancy party was AWFUL.

What the fuck am i missing here? Going by your 'previews' listed here, Spartacus is great television and Fringe and Supernatural are repetitive crap.  What are you smoking AVclub? Spartacus is a god awful, painfully cheesy show with very little FEMALE nudity. They offer you plenty of penis if that's your thing.

This episode was weak, very few funny moments. How you grade this the same as the premiere a few weeks back with burt reynolds or the train episode is insanity. Is everything an A at the AVclub?

Last episode i'll watch of this. Man this show is bad. 

Sheen destroyed the show MJF made.

I'd actually respect him calling out the show for being the shit that it is….if he didn't spend 8 seasons on it. 

I'll never understand why so many people would watch Big Bang (which was only funny for the first season then nosedived into CBS Sitcom Shit Factory oblivion) over this show. Community is hilarious.

I still believe Peter is in a different universe entirely. Earth 1 and 2 are one universe. Earth 3 and 4 are a separate universe, and so on. They said that anybody getting sick in town had their doppelganger on the other side, causing them to get sick becuase they were merging two beings into one. Therefore, the other…

WOW! Incredible episode. Boyd is the best criminal I've seen on TV for quite some time. Only an asshole would think he could compete against superior forces. Love how the show points this out from Boyd's perspective even though we all knew it to be true. He'll find his window and cease the opportunity.

I agree, this show is about five years removed from being genuinely funny. My expectations are so low for this show that a decent episode is good to me. Very low standards for Family Guy.

Good episode but not a single scene of Jones who perpetrated the entire act? Pretty weak Fringe.

This show is great, another solid episode. I never watched a full episode of the Cleveland Show, I can never make it past a few minutes of an episode, but I feel like this show is much better than Family Guy because it actually tells a story instead of trying to hammer you with random skits that have nothing to do…

They had me at 'Halloween 4, or the greatest movie of all time.'

This episode had everything I love about Supernatural - great writing and acting (although the villain was pretty weak) and very funny moments sprinkled throughout. Although the show will never come close to the quality of years 1 - 5, it's episodes like this that makes me glad it's still on the air. Easy A- rating…

This should have been a great episode…mediocre at best. C rating for me.

Yeah, seasons 1 -3 are rough, funny, but the least funny by far in the series. Kramer didn't even leave the apartment building the first two seasons.

Desperate for a quality sitcom to watch, with no more Community or Sunny to enjoy, I gave this show a chance. It was pretty funny the first two or three seasons. Then it dropped off…massively. I stopped watching in season four, should have stayed that way. Every scene that doesn't involve Alec Baldwin is painful to…

Any news on when NBC dumps the awful 30 Rock to bring back Community? 

Seinfeld still trumps every single sitcom on TV today. Community and Always Sunny are the best of the best, but even they don't hold a candle to a show 15 years old. 

I'd like to concur with with you on all points but Dickie seems like a carbon copy of his character from Lost. All the mannerisms are the same. Bring something new to the table Davies.