I still believe the scene was a little off in tone, but I wouldn't say it was out-of-character and I think you quite nailed it with your description.

The abrupt appearance of Bobby is suspicious. If he is Leviathan, that's  lame. That would make no sense. Worst twist, ever. I think that would rip huge plot holes in the entire arc.

He definitely should have killed the kid, out of mercy. Off-screen would be fine by me. It made no sense this way. I can't imagine that he didn't think it through enough to be surprised by the kid being there.

Like Lola says, Dean can't be left alone, because what makes him a freak is based in behavior patterns, not tied to tangible entities you can erase from existence (assuming you can).

Yeah, that was a fantastically awkward scene, with that look afterwards and all…well played.

It got real bad before they cancelled it. The finale was clicheed crap (the "spinning camera in the dark room" for one was terrible) and didn't create much hope for a second season. The real finale in my mind was the second-to-last episode.

Because they have different issues that the house or whatever brings to light with a different kind of haunting. Sort of In Treatment if it was horror.
That's the only way I can imagine this might work. That might still not be enough to avoid repetition. Maybe each family will get closer to stop the haunting?

It already seems obvious that some (or all?) of the guest characters running around are ghosts in the flesh. There will be no trouble bringing the Harmons back, together with a new family and build on past events in the second season.

No, it's not. Unless SMG is playing it wrong…
There are vulnerable moments when she is alone on-screen, related to either Bridget or Henry.

You don't have much of an imagination, then. I don't think it was complete shit. I like both, but I don't like Moffat that much more than you do, apparently.

I feel the same way. It's different. That's enough for now.
With all the things happening I can't think of anything to say about the show. That should be a pretty good indicator that there is nothing there…

"Sam also fills the Mercedes role, since he's Emily's former sweetheart and still carries a (somewhat creepy) torch for her"
That would be Jack. Sam(my) is the dog.
Although that's fine, I guess. The dog also carries a somewhat creepy torch for her, seeing that he extended his life expectancy until he meets her again.

In this episode Emily made a reference to this - the greatest mystery no doubt - by calling the dog "oldtimer".

It wasn't a commenter, it was the reviewer himself. And I agree with him. That was the best scene. I like the delivery of Dennings and Behrs. Unfortunately, most jokes are so bad that it doesn't help make it funny.

Max takes Chestnut the Horse to the trash cans in the back of the diner each morning. I am going to assume that she also feeds it from that trash. Prior to the shitting, hopefully. Or they take leftovers back to their place.
Also, I don't think comedy has to make much sense, if it's funny. Which it isn't, so far.…

Agreed. That scene put me off. I thought, "Who is this guy? Do I know him?". And I think Laurie thought the same thing while saying it.
Maybe House would say something like that, but not this way. It sounded like Laurie was trying to deliver those lines as fast as he possibly could just to get it out of his brain and…

Conventions and uninspired writing are not the same thing. I like plenty of television. I no longer like to watch House (and I used to love it up to and including season 5). Suffered through season 6 and gave up on 7 early on.
Had to watch this episode out of curiosity. But it was no good, for all the reasons stated…

They look absolutely nothing alike. And they have completely different mannerisms on top of that. Plus, "Rubicon" is a better actor and Rubicon was a good show (until the final episode which was really quite bad). 
You got everything wrong. But at least you hate River Song and we got that in common. ;)

I like the improvisation scenes, too. Although most of them are probably unrealistic, as their solution is convenient. Never mind that, it's the most fun.

That was the best Winchester scene in quite some time. In fact, I can't remember a scene as good in any of season 6. Simply because it felt different this time.