Fair enough.  My top 3 for the season will be the ones listed above, all three being my "A's" for the season ("Cold Stones" will also get an "A").  Members Only is certainly a great episode, it sets up Season 6 perfectly. I love the story of Eugene Pontecorvo, and find his hanging to be one of the darkest things I've…

Fair enough.  My top 3 for the season will be the ones listed above, all three being my "A's" for the season ("Cold Stones" will also get an "A").  Members Only is certainly a great episode, it sets up Season 6 perfectly. I love the story of Eugene Pontecorvo, and find his hanging to be one of the darkest things I've…

I'm glad to see someone else who didn't really enjoy "Mr. Ruggerio's Neighborhood".  It's an interesting episode, but nowhere near the classic many people proclaim it.  "Proshai, Livuska" is a far superior episode, forgetting the awful fake Nancy Marchand.

I'm glad to see someone else who didn't really enjoy "Mr. Ruggerio's Neighborhood".  It's an interesting episode, but nowhere near the classic many people proclaim it.  "Proshai, Livuska" is a far superior episode, forgetting the awful fake Nancy Marchand.

This is wholly superior to "Johnny Cakes" in every way.  This is my favorite kind of Sopranos episode, where all the supernatural stuff comes to a head and, as someone put it in the comments here, you realize these people are headed for an eternal damnation of some sort.

This is wholly superior to "Johnny Cakes" in every way.  This is my favorite kind of Sopranos episode, where all the supernatural stuff comes to a head and, as someone put it in the comments here, you realize these people are headed for an eternal damnation of some sort.

Yeah, this is a B- episode at best.  It would be in contention for "Worst Sopranos episode" if not for the fantastic scene between A.J. and Tony at the police station, which feels like a point we've been building towards for several seasons now.  But the simple truth is this: Gannascoli cannot sell the sheer tragedy…

Yeah, this is a B- episode at best.  It would be in contention for "Worst Sopranos episode" if not for the fantastic scene between A.J. and Tony at the police station, which feels like a point we've been building towards for several seasons now.  But the simple truth is this: Gannascoli cannot sell the sheer tragedy…