I admit it was rather silly that a master thief was actually in a photograph so blatantly wearing the spoils of his thievery, yet no one could catch him.  I think I could have used a few more in-depth deductions from Sherlock to connect a few more dots…. just anything to make it less obvious that the guy was Le…

… You'd rather they show the real criminal behind it all during the promos?  Or blatantly let you know before you even see the episode that Le Chevalier was a red herring all along?

… You'd rather they show the real criminal behind it all during the promos?  Or blatantly let you know before you even see the episode that Le Chevalier was a red herring all along?

I'm exactly the same way.  I can never remember which episode is which case but I definitely remember which episode had which Holmes-Watson interaction in it.  I've grown invested in the progress of their relationship and I watch the show purely to see more.

I'm exactly the same way.  I can never remember which episode is which case but I definitely remember which episode had which Holmes-Watson interaction in it.  I've grown invested in the progress of their relationship and I watch the show purely to see more.

The recap is wrong in the mention of no siblings.  The exact line of dialogue for that part of the recap goes:

The recap is wrong in the mention of no siblings.  The exact line of dialogue for that part of the recap goes:

I agree.  The beginning half of this episode when the plot revolved purely around solving the "how" of the cracked safe excited me, just because it was something new and different.  And then a dead body popped up to turn the mystery back into the standard homicide.  I was really disappointed.  There are plenty of…

I agree.  The beginning half of this episode when the plot revolved purely around solving the "how" of the cracked safe excited me, just because it was something new and different.  And then a dead body popped up to turn the mystery back into the standard homicide.  I was really disappointed.  There are plenty of…

I think Dan's reaction was understandable, but still a bit cold.  We don't know precisely how hard the pressure against this guy is, and in some ways (basic societal ways, not civil rights) the pressure against being single is similar to the pressure against being gay.  Our society is formed so much around…

I think Dan's reaction was understandable, but still a bit cold.  We don't know precisely how hard the pressure against this guy is, and in some ways (basic societal ways, not civil rights) the pressure against being single is similar to the pressure against being gay.  Our society is formed so much around…

Even way back when in 2008, I'm pretty sure pipe bomb diagrams were available on the internet.

Even way back when in 2008, I'm pretty sure pipe bomb diagrams were available on the internet.

EDIT: Never mind. I'm an idiot, and I'm deleting all proof by editing this post. Hi!

EDIT: Never mind. I'm an idiot, and I'm deleting all proof by editing this post. Hi!

I disagree.  Maybe I'm the only person on here to think so, but I don't really see her as a tremendously strong actress.  What did she do on House besides walk around with a low-cut top and a half-confused smirk?  She did the same thing on this episode of Elementary.  I'm glad she turned into a one-off character that…

I disagree.  Maybe I'm the only person on here to think so, but I don't really see her as a tremendously strong actress.  What did she do on House besides walk around with a low-cut top and a half-confused smirk?  She did the same thing on this episode of Elementary.  I'm glad she turned into a one-off character that…

Indeed, while the clues all add up to suggest that Edelstein’s character was the culprit, the episode never bothers to reveal a number of key details, chief among them why any public relations executive would turn to a pipe bomb to eliminate a blackmail threat.

Indeed, while the clues all add up to suggest that Edelstein’s character was the culprit, the episode never bothers to reveal a number of key details, chief among them why any public relations executive would turn to a pipe bomb to eliminate a blackmail threat.

What happens at the Farm of Death stays at the Farm of Death.