Oh God YES! The Heidecker and Huebel episodes of Who Charted have been magnificent.

I tried three episodes of MATES and found they were nothing special, just ok. Maybe I just find snack talk unengaging as a whole and it's not that those two guys are unengaging, it's that anyone's boring when they're talking snacks.

I feel like the straight music guests are killing the fun a little too but this week with Kroll and Silverman was just a delight.

JORDAN JESSE GO was amazing with Maron dropping by this week. He's always a good guest on any podcast but something about him being buddy-buddy with Jesse and the natural silliness of JJGo elevated that show above the others this week.

This week on the internet's longest running, most passionately beloved full-time professional comedy chat podcast KEITH & THE GIRL:

Yeah, Hodgman is great but the lame guests have killed that show.

Build A Title is very fun to play but a drag to listen to. Even the inherently flawed Len Maltin Game is a drag half the time because half the guests are just no good at it.

"Literally everyone"? You actually think NOBODY predicted the crash?

I can take or leave DiPaolo too. There's plenty of the time I'm not impressed by him, but then I feel like if he's ok with Louis who am I to judge?

Yeah, Gould is gold on any show but his chemistry with Carolla is the best.

I prefered the Canadian one but this week's was plenty of fun too. I love how cute Glass and Baker were that when it came time for her to spill on Ira's drunken debauchery the story was of a man playing typically frustrated Pictionary. This Rock'n'roll Life!

Each week when I reach The Rest and read the semi-dismissive Podmass round-up of the Carolla show I think to myself, "Yeah, that sums it up pretty well," and yet when I'm listening I feel like even with his tendency to re-tell stories and re-complain irrelevant complaints he and his team still put out five of the…

Awesome job on the pinata Meredith, I'm genuinely stoked for you.

I'm with you Joel. Even when the in-studio shows have guests I really like they felt really flat and I found I would stop listening to them about 8 minutes in. Now I just skip them.

Even though I listen to a zillion American podcasts I always figure as a filthy foreigner that American comedy fans know American comedy folks better than I do.

Perfect quote and write up for the LISA LAMPANELLI ep of WTF this week.

That's because he is really fucking funny.

Yep, it suffers from the same malady as Best Show. Too many boring/irritating callers getting in the way of a good host.

I voted for Matt Besser to win but then I have a history of not understanding modern game shows.

He was great bouncing off TJ MILLER on DOUG LOVES MOVIES this week too and even since before his profile shot up with Last Comic Standing he's been a brilliant regular guest on KEITH AND THE GIRL for maybe three years now.