I haven't watched it for a few months so I don't feel very fresh in critiquing it but I basically mean all three of the things you say. Maybe with the exception of Andy, who I think has a random "good" switch, the characters have all done or said things that are shitty and at the same somewhat arbitrary—and seemingly…

eh I thought he was a bit of a cheeseball. Maybe I was off my game last night.

for some reason I'm envisioning a tall nonobese black man winning this year. We'll see if I'm close at all.

I was waffling between a joke about "beating the odds" against having a blonde afro and joking about he must have been a really bad kid to warrant getting kicked out of all those houses. I went with nothing.

if it were a Lifetime Original Movie all the girls in it would be pregnant and Thora Birch would be there making a video blog about the whole thing.

Oh I dunno I think it was more his weirdness than anything else. Maybe I live in a self-deluded utopia though where we judge weirdos for their weirdness, and not their gayness.

Santino is on RuPaul's Drag Race, the most awesome show ever

yeah her boobs distracted me too—they were so cleavagey for such a small lady.

oh wow, I totally didn't remember him from PR.

take it away, Christy!

exactly, I think that's what bothers me most about the clip show in this instance. I know with TV you're supposed to something your disbesomething, but it does bug me when the show messes too much with the documentary format and this is a glaring example.

stupid edits take so long to get published.

this is edifying. But yeah I'm so dim I didn't start figuring out until Tuesday when I was like, WAIT A MINUTE THAT HOTEL IS NOWHERE NEAR THE UNITED CENTER!

That's nice to hear although I was really hoping to pick on them. Now you've gone and humanized them. But yeah probably they are more "White Christmas" sisters than, um, "Whorey White Christmas" sisters

I think "So You Think YOu Can Dance" has made me jaded towards pants-splitting.

I did and it pained me to do so but my ambivalence about the show was affecting the writeups. I watched it later but not dedicatedly—it would sit around in my DVR for a few weeks before I got to it. I might give season 2 a few episode tryout but drop it after that if it doesn't grab me.

I can't believe he's rocking it still. I thought it might have disappeared into the night.

speaking of ryan high-fiving the blind kid, did anybody catch a re-enactment of that on New Years day on ESPN when the announcer tried to shake the blind kid's hand? I thought of you guys.

I will have to see a picture to decide for myself.

I really couldn't get into this show
I wanted to—I love Toni Collette so much, and it's such a great idea. But I guess I didn't really like any of the characters, except maybe Gimme of course.