avclub-4c56ff4ce4aaf9573aa5dff913df997a--disqus
Claire Zulkey
avclub-4c56ff4ce4aaf9573aa5dff913df997a--disqus

I'm not crapping on hydrangeas! It's not like they're carnations or something.

ha! I'm glad that quote got included in the piece somehow. I decided it was a little over-the-top for this writeup.

ha I noticed that she got hydrangeas too. I wonder what that says about us.

I know: I'm waiting for a new batch to come in to the Fox publicity site—I can only use horizontal photos for some reason so that limits the choices.

he totally does seem like a bro, which was funny to me at the beginning of the season when Simon saw Indian guy + plaid shirt and assumed it meant nerd. he failed to see the khakis and flip flops I guess.

that must be the reason why he looks…odd. He's trying to change his coloring/complexion which never works 100%.

oh is he the new rock of love guy? I heard there was a new rock of love guy.

McPhee's face>McPhee's voice

I watched Blade Runner and Rocky Horror Picture Show both one night at a Catholic youth group sleepover and they both made the same amount of sense to me (although Rocky Horror was more entertaining). But who would have thought they would both lead up to Idol in some way?

squee back at you! here I'll make that little kitty face ^__^

there was a general lack of funk, this is true—but it was never explained really what they were supposed to do with disco anyway so I guess that gave them leeway. lack of funk=amazing interpretation?

I agree it's a more talented group but the B- is for the ep in general—it just felt rather eh to me.

Well I was watching "Grease" when I was in the single-digits and a loooooot of stuff went over my head that I didn't get hep to until I was older. I was scandalized when I listened to the lyrics in "Greased Lightning"

oooh, the adenoids…also, better watch out for your toothbrush bristles or you might have to get your appendix out!

Werdsmiff, the image of Dahl's nose being all but sheared off in "Boy" is forever seared on my brain.

tha'ts really cute, Oranjemonkey.

The funny thing is comparing this show so SYTYCD, which is so gay it's a nonissue.

my mom and I were having a discussion about Adam last night and I think that for all the makeup and drag and over-the-top performances he doesn't seem like a very over-the-top, flamboyant person, you know? He's sort of a macho glam and I dig that about him.

I guess what I mean is that I don't think his sexuality is a big issue ON the show. I feel like Nathaniel was kind of more the "gay contestant," sort of alluding to his sexuality on the show, more than Adam.

good point Isaac, I forgot that she kept fiddling with her earpiece too.